First, the violation notice against my drainage work was void. The two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar fine that came with it was voided with it. My drainage work was not an unapproved alteration, and the notice should not have been issued. Alan said this plainly, without blaming anyone by name for the notice itself, but the effect was the same: the fine was gone, and the record would show it had never stood.
Second, Patricia Doyle was personally liable for the cost of the damage to my lawn. The amount was five thousand six hundred and forty dollars. Alan broke it down the way I had broken it down: three thousand eight hundred and fifty dollars for repair labor and materials, six hundred and forty dollars for irrigation work, and one thousand one hundred and fifty dollars for the survey. He said the word "personally" twice, and the second time he looked directly at Patricia.
"The board is explicit on this point," he said. "This amount is to be paid by Mrs. Doyle personally. It is not to be paid from HOA funds, and it is not to be treated as an association expense."
That mattered more than I had expected it to. I had worried, in the back of my mind, that the board would find a way to spread the cost across the neighborhood, which would have turned every neighbor into a reluctant party to the repair and made the whole thing worse. Alan closed that door before anyone could open it.
Third, Patricia was ordered to issue a written apology to me and to the board. Alan did not dictate the wording. He said the apology was to acknowledge the damage, the incorrect reliance on the sales-brochure map rather than the recorded plat, and the violation notice that had followed. It was to be delivered in writing, within fourteen days.
Fourth, the board recorded that the repair work was to proceed, and that I was free to have it done by my own crew, with the cost covered by Patricia's payment. There was no condition attached that I use anyone else, and no suggestion that I do the work for free. That, too, mattered. I had built the estimate as a contractor, and the board was treating it as a contractor's estimate, not as a favor I owed the neighborhood.
Alan also made clear that the findings would be sent to both of us in writing, and that they would be recorded in the board's minutes. That mattered to me, because a verbal decision in a community room can soften with retelling, while a written finding stays where it was put. I had spent three weeks watching a sales-brochure map do the work of a recorded plat, simply because it was the paper people had on hand, and I did not want the outcome of this hearing to depend on anyone's memory of what Alan had said. The minutes would say the fine was void, the amount was five thousand six hundred and forty dollars, and the payment was personal. Anyone who read them later would not have to take my word for it.
When Alan finished, he asked Patricia whether she understood the findings. She said yes, in a voice that was quieter than the one she had used during her own presentation. He asked me whether I understood them. I said yes. He adjourned the hearing, and the room emptied slowly, the way rooms empty after something serious has happened and nobody is quite sure whether they are supposed to talk about it in the parking lot.
Tom walked out with me. He did not congratulate me. He just said, "That was fair," and I agreed with him, because it was. Fairness, in this case, had a number attached to it, and the number was five thousand six hundred and forty dollars, paid by the person who had caused the damage, not by the neighborhood she had presided over.
Patricia's written apology arrived nine days later, in an envelope with no HOA letterhead, addressed to me in her own handwriting. I read it standing in my kitchen, the same place I had read the hearing notice, and I read it twice, the way I had read that.
It was short, and it was not warm, but it was not evasive either. She wrote that she had driven onto my lawn during Madison's engagement party, that the damage that followed was hers, and that she had been wrong about the plat. She wrote that the map she had relied on was a developer's sales brochure, not the recorded plat, and that the county easement did not give her the right to park on my property. She wrote that the violation notice and the fine should not have been issued, and that she was sorry for both the damage and the weeks that had followed it. She addressed a copy to the board as well, and Alan later confirmed that the board had received it.