“Then can you confirm that the current concept avoids the easement entirely?”
Voss looked toward the screen. “We will provide a written response after legal review.”
A man in the back raised his hand and asked whether the development would include a connection to Alder Creek's private road. Another asked about traffic. A woman wanted to know whether the wetlands would attract mosquitoes. The meeting moved on, but Marianne remained focused on the blue oval. She had seen enough drainage plans to know that a decorative pond could not substitute for a broad natural storage corridor unless the engineers had accounted for volume, flow, soil, and downstream capacity. The rendering supplied none of those details.
After the presentation, Rafael found her beside a table of brochures. He had attended quietly and taken photographs of the slides. “The road is on top of the old channel,” he said. “They may intend to move it, but if they do, they need to show where the water goes during a major storm. Their pond is too small to hold the volume shown on the original plat.”
“Can you prove that from a rendering?”
“No. We need a hydrologic model and the actual grading plan. The rendering tells us what they want people to imagine, not what they intend to build.”
Marianne thanked him. Across the room, Grant was speaking with Voss and a man wearing a North Fork name badge. When he saw Marianne watching, he separated from the group and came toward her. “You should not have questioned them like that,” he said.
“Why not?”
“Because you made the association look hostile.”
“I asked whether a road crossed our drainage easement.”
“You implied they were hiding something.”
“I asked a question. They declined to answer.”
Grant lowered his voice. “North Fork may be willing to contribute to our pond restoration. They have resources. If we antagonize them, we lose an opportunity.”
“An opportunity to do what?”
“To repair the system without raising assessments.”
Marianne looked at him. “Did they offer money?”
“Not formally.”
“Did you discuss our water-management fund with them?”
“I discussed the neighborhood's needs.”
“On whose authority?”
Grant's expression hardened. “You are not the only person entitled to speak for this community.”
“No,” Marianne said. “But I am the person elected to chair the board, and the board has not authorized you to negotiate a contribution or share private financial records.”
He turned away before she finished. She watched him rejoin Voss, then took one of the brochures. A small line of text at the bottom listed the project entity as North Fork Development Partners LLC, managed by a holding company registered in Delaware. The brochure gave no contact for the engineer responsible for stormwater design.
On Tuesday, Marianne met Samuel Reed in his office above a pharmacy on Main Street. The room smelled of old books and lemon polish. Reed read the 1998 letter, the original plat, and the 2006 Northline contract without interruption. He asked for the full recorded easement, the association declaration, the current management agreement, and the minutes from every board meeting involving the pond. He did not react when she described Grant's role in the North Fork meeting. “I can review the documents,” he said. “I cannot conclude from a photograph that someone has violated an easement. But I can tell you that the association has a duty to preserve records, follow its governing documents, and avoid authorizing work that could impair a protected drainage route.”
“Can I hire you without the entire board approving?”
“That depends on your bylaws and the engagement terms. You can obtain preliminary advice in your individual capacity, but I would not represent that I am association counsel until the board authorizes it. If the board refuses, we can discuss how an owner might seek records or request a meeting under the declaration.”
He reviewed the board's authority provisions and found that the president could obtain advice necessary to evaluate an immediate threat, subject to later reporting. He offered to prepare a limited memorandum for a fixed fee. Marianne signed an engagement letter from her own account, with the understanding that the association could reimburse the expense if the board approved it. Reed made one request: “Do not tell me what you think happened. Tell me what the papers say. The difference is usually where the case begins.”