Then came the special assessment.
It arrived in the mail one spring morning, printed on the same letterhead, signed by the same hand: a one-time special assessment of $1,800, per household, for a clubhouse pool-house renovation. The letter described the work in broad terms — new roofing, new plumbing, new flooring — and it gave a start date, and it asked for payment within thirty days. Julian had paid it, because everyone paid it, because that was what you did when the association asked, and because $1,800 was a lot of money but not so much that he wanted a fight over it.
Months passed. The pool house was not renovated. No contractors arrived. No work began. The clubhouse sat exactly as it always had, its roof unchanged, its plumbing untouched, its flooring the same worn carpet it had always had. Julian drove past it every day on his way to work, and every day he looked at it and thought about the $1,800, and about the start date that had come and gone, and about the fact that no one on the board seemed to be asking where the money had gone.
He began to ask.
Julian asked for the books the way an engineer asks for anything: politely, in writing, with a clear request and a reasonable deadline. He wrote to the board, and he asked for the HOA's financial records — the assessment fund, the receipts, the contractor bids, the bank statements — everything that would show where the $1,800 per household had gone, and why the pool-house renovation had never started.
The response came from Harriet herself, in a letter that was short and cool and did not answer his question. The records were being compiled, she wrote. The board would review them at the annual meeting. There was no need for individual homeowners to concern themselves with the details. The association's finances were in order, and the renovation would proceed in due course.
Julian read the letter twice, and then he read it a third time, and he knew, with the same cold clarity he had felt by the pool, that it was not an answer. It was a delay. He wrote again, more specifically this time, asking for the bank statements for the assessment fund, and for the names of the contractors who had been paid, and for the dates of the payments. The second letter took longer to arrive, and when it did, it was shorter than the first, and it told him that the records were not available for individual review, and that he should bring his questions to the annual meeting.
He did the math himself, then, sitting at his kitchen table with a notepad and a calculator, the way he did when a set of drawings did not add up. There were more than a hundred homes in Magnolia Trace. At $1,800 each, the assessment should have raised well over $180,000. The pool-house renovation, even done properly, should have cost a fraction of that, and it had not been done at all. The numbers didn't add up. They did not add up by a little. They did not add up by a lot, and the more he looked at them, the worse they looked.
He told Adele about it, over coffee at her kitchen table, and she listened the way she always listened, without interrupting, and when he finished, she said only that he should be careful, and that people who handled other people's money did not like being asked where it had gone. He told her he would be careful. He told her he was only asking for records, and that asking for records was not an accusation, and that any board with nothing to hide would show him the books. He believed that, too, when he said it. He believed that a straightforward question deserved a straightforward answer, and that the annual meeting would be the place where the answer finally came, in front of witnesses, where it could not be delayed again.
But he knew, even as he said it, that Harriet Quinn was not the kind of person who showed anyone the books. She was the kind of person who told you to wait for the annual meeting, and who hoped you would forget by then, or lose interest, or decide it was not worth the fight.