HOA Tried to Ban My Service Dog — So I Got the Justice Department Involved and Bankrupted the Association

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I opened it.

Patricia.

Again.

This time she wasn't alone.

A gray-haired man stood beside her.

He wore a polo shirt with a small Whispering Oaks logo embroidered over the chest.

"Mike," Patricia said.

"Patricia."

"This is Harold Benton. Our architectural review committee chair."

Harold gave me a polite smile.

"Welcome."

"Thank you."

Patricia looked past me.

"May we come in?"

"No."

Her smile disappeared.

"Excuse me?"

"You asked if you could come in."

"Yes."

"And I'm saying no."

Harold looked uncomfortable.

Patricia recovered quickly.

"We need to inspect the property."

"For what?"

"Several potential violations."

I looked at Harold.

"Did you schedule an inspection?"

"No."

"Then you can't come in."

Patricia crossed her arms.

"This is an HOA community."

"I know."

"You agreed to the covenants when you purchased the property."

"I agreed to reasonable community rules. I didn't agree to strangers walking through my house."

Harold cleared his throat.

"Perhaps we can simply discuss things outside."

"Sure."

Patricia stepped backward.

"Your mailbox is incorrect."

I looked at it.

It was a standard black mailbox.

"What's wrong with it?"

"Wrong finish."

"It's black."

"It must be matte black."

I stared at her.

"It is matte black."

She frowned.

"Your porch light."

"What's wrong with it?"

"Not approved."

"I bought it from the previous owner."

"That doesn't mean it was approved."

"The house was sold with it."

"That doesn't grandfather everything."

I looked at Harold.

"Is this normal?"

Harold hesitated.

"Patricia is very thorough."

That wasn't an answer.

Patricia pulled another sheet from her clipboard.

"Your trash cans are visible from the street."

"It's trash day tomorrow."

"They're supposed to be placed at the curb no earlier than 6:00 a.m."

"It's 7:00 p.m."

"Exactly."

"So I can't put them out yet."

"Correct."

I nodded.

"Anything else?"

She checked her list.

"Your dog."

"Again?"

"Yes."

"He's a service animal."

"That remains under review."

"Under review by whom?"

"The association."

"You're not a medical authority."

Patricia's jaw tightened.

"We'll discuss this later."

She turned.

Then looked over her shoulder.

"One final thing."

"What?"

"You're parked in your driveway."

I looked behind me.

My truck was gone.

My car was parked perfectly between the lines.

"That's where people usually park."

"Your front tires are three inches too close to the sidewalk."

I stared at her.

She stared back.

Then Harold whispered:

"Patricia."

She ignored him.

"I recommend you familiarize yourself with the rules."

"I will."

She smiled.

"I hope you do."

Then they left.

Atlas walked over.

He sniffed the doorway.

I closed it.

For the first time since I'd bought the house, I wondered whether I had made a mistake.

That night, I sat at my kitchen table and read the entire HOA covenant.

Forty-seven pages.

I highlighted seventeen rules.

Most were ordinary.

No abandoned vehicles.

Maintain landscaping.

No excessive noise.

No structures without approval.

Then I found something interesting.

Article 12.

Association authority concerning community safety and property access.

The wording was vague.

Very vague.

It gave the board broad authority to inspect properties under certain circumstances.

But there was no specific rule about service animals.

There was no blanket ban on large dogs.

And there was nothing that said Patricia could enter my house.

I leaned back.

"Interesting."

Atlas lifted his head.

I smiled.

"Don't worry, buddy."

He put his head down again.

I kept reading.

Then I noticed something else.

The HOA had been incorporated only three years earlier.

But the neighborhood was nearly twenty years old.

Why?

I opened my laptop.

I searched the county property records.

Then the HOA registration.

Then the corporation filings.

At 11:42 p.m., I found something strange.

Whispering Oaks Homeowners Association had originally been called:

Whispering Oaks Residential Development Association.

Its original president had been a man named:

Richard Pringle.

Patricia's husband.

I kept reading.

Richard had resigned from the board two years earlier.

And six months after his resignation, Patricia had become president.

I stared at the screen.

"Okay."

Atlas opened one eye.

"Now I'm curious."

The next morning, I found an envelope taped to my front door.

No stamp.

No address.

Just my name.

Inside was a formal violation notice.

NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE

Property: 124 Maple Drive.

Violations:

  1. Unauthorized service animal.

  2. Improper landscaping.

  3. Unapproved exterior lighting.

  4. Improper vehicle positioning.

  5. Failure to submit architectural modification request.

  6. Potential security concern regarding oversized canine.

The last line was handwritten.

News in the same category

HOA Tried to Ban My Service Dog — So I Got the Justice Department Involved and Bankrupted the Association

7 Part