That was when I decided the situation had to be addressed.
I went to her house.
"Sandra, can we talk?"
She opened the door with a smile.
"Of course."
I explained calmly.
The original agreement had been occasional.
The number of visits had become excessive.
Guests were coming over without asking.
And, most importantly, people were entering my backyard while I was not home.
I told her I wasn't comfortable with that.
"I understand," she said.
Then came the sentence I still remember.
"I just thought you were more open to sharing."
There was something about the wording.
Not I'm sorry.
Not I misunderstood.
Instead, the implication was that my unwillingness to continue sharing my property on her preferred terms was somehow a personality defect.
I simply said, "Going forward, access is going to be much more limited."
She nodded.
"Okay."
I went home.
I thought the matter was settled.
The pool season ended.
I added a new lock to the gate.
October passed.
November passed.
Winter came.
And for several months, Sandra left the subject alone.
Then spring returned.
And with it came the problem.
The first sign that Sandra had decided my decision didn't really matter was the fence.
The fence separating our properties was old but sturdy.
Six feet high.
Wooden.
It had existed before either Sandra or I had purchased our homes.
In late May, I noticed something unusual.
Two boards near the section of fence closest to my pool were loose.
At first, I assumed weather had caused the damage.
Then I examined them.
The screws weren't rusted.
The wood wasn't rotten.
The boards had been pushed inward.
Someone had deliberately created a gap.
The opening was about eighteen inches wide.
Large enough for a child.
Large enough for an adult who was willing to squeeze.
And on the other side was Sandra's backyard.
I repaired the boards.
I added additional fasteners.
I didn't confront Sandra.
I wanted to believe it had been accidental.
That was the accountant in me, perhaps.
Don't assume intent when facts are insufficient.
I repaired the evidence and waited.
Three weeks later, I left town for work.
I was gone for six days.
When I returned, I noticed something immediately.
The pool chemistry was wrong.
The chlorine level had dropped sharply.
The water wasn't dangerous, but it had clearly experienced a significant increase in bather load.
There was also something sitting beside the pool.
A pink flip-flop.
It wasn't mine.
I looked toward the fence.
The boards were damaged again.
The gap was open.
The additional screws I had installed had been pulled out.
I stood there for a long time.
Then I went inside.
That evening, I made a decision.
I wasn't going to argue with Sandra.
I wasn't going to yell.
I wasn't going to threaten her.
I was going to document.
The next morning, I hired a security company.
Four cameras.
One facing the pool.
One covering the rear patio.
Two covering the fence and gate areas.
Motion activation.
Night vision.
Cloud storage.
Automatic timestamps.
I tested every camera myself.
Then I tested them again.
I wanted no blind spots.
The first week was quiet.
Then the camera notifications began.
The first recording showed Sandra and her children entering the pool area through the gap in the fence.
The second showed the same thing three days later.
The third included Sandra's sister.
The fourth showed four children.
The fifth happened after dark.
That one changed something in me.
I watched Sandra step through the fence gap at 9:42 p.m.
She looked around.
Then she walked toward the pool.
The children followed.
They turned on the patio lights.
They entered the water.
I was upstairs in my bedroom at the time.
I had no idea they were there.
I watched the recording twice.
Then I downloaded it.
I created a folder.
POOL ACCESS — DOCUMENTATION
Inside it, I created subfolders by month.
May.
June.
July.
August.
I also created a spreadsheet.
Date.
Time.
People present.
Entry point.
Activity.
Duration.
Evidence file.
It was almost embarrassingly methodical.
But that was how I worked.
I didn't know how far this situation would go.
I only knew that if it did go further, I didn't want to rely on memory.
By the end of July, I had documented eleven unauthorized entries.
Four included guests.
Three occurred after dark.
Two involved Sandra using my pool equipment.
On one occasion, she used my pool brush.
On another, she took one of my floating loungers into the water.
I found this particularly strange.
It was as if she had crossed the psychological line from someone using a pool to someone behaving as though the pool belonged to her.
That distinction mattered.
So I continued documenting.
I also gathered everything proving the pool belonged to me.
The original construction contract from Aqua Design Solutions.
The county building permit.
The final inspection certificate.
The insurance declaration listing the pool as an improvement on my property.
Photographs from construction.
Tax records.
Twelve years of maintenance invoices.
Every invoice had my name.
My address.
My pool.
I even found an old photograph taken the week the concrete shell was poured.
I had forgotten I possessed it.
There it was.
The empty backyard.
The construction crew.
The concrete shell.
And me standing beside it, wearing a ridiculous sun hat and holding a folder of paperwork.
I smiled when I saw it.
Then I added it to the file.
By early August, I hired a contractor to permanently repair the fence.
The damaged boards were removed.