"Do you remember the summer you got into Stanford?" she asked.
"Of course," I said. "We had that big party in the backyard. Mom made that terrible blue cake."
"I spent that entire party in the bathroom crying," Clara said. "Not because I wasn't happy for you. But because I realized that from that moment on, I would only ever be 'Elena’s sister.' I saw the way Dad looked at you—like you were a trophy he’d finally won. And then he looked at me, and I saw him lower his expectations in real-time. I became the 'artistic' one because it was the only category left where I didn't have to compete with a ghost."
I felt a sickening jolt of shock. That summer was one of my brightest memories—a time of family unity and celebration. To hear it described as the site of her emotional erasure felt like having a floorboard give way beneath my feet.
"I never wanted you to feel that way," I stammered. "I always tried to encourage you."
"Your encouragement felt like a lecture, Elena," she replied, her voice gaining a steady, sharp edge. "Every time you told me I should 'dream bigger' or 'get out of that town,' what I heard was that I wasn't enough as I was. You weren't cheering for me; you were cheering for a version of me that looked more like you."