When Laura came home, I confessed everything. She was furious—at Karen for the relentless trespassing, but equally at me for letting my pride orchestrate a stupid prank that could have landed me in jail.
The next day, I hired a contractor. We replaced the wooden gate with a heavy, wrought-iron security gate equipped with a digital keypad deadbolt. The hinges were welded shut.
Karen never spoke to us again. A few months later, a "For Sale" sign appeared in her front yard. I watched the moving truck pull away just as the autumn leaves began to fall, perfectly blanketing the cover of our quiet, private pool.