“If This Is the Price, I’ll Pay It,” He Said — But Something in His Eyes Stopped Her

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Don't."

Caleb lowered his revolver.

Pike stepped inside.

He took the ledger.

For a moment, triumph filled his face.

Then he opened it.

His expression changed.

"What's this?"

Caleb watched him.

Names.

Dates.

Payments.

Locations.

Pike's smile disappeared.

One name appeared repeatedly.

Elias Mercer.

Another appeared beside it.

Amos Pike.

Caleb stared.

Pike's face went pale.

"You knew."

Caleb said nothing.

Pike ripped the page out.

Taya's eyes narrowed.

"You can't destroy the truth."

Pike looked at her.

"Truth is whatever survives."

He handed the ledger to one of his men.

"Burn it."

Caleb stepped forward.

Pike raised his gun.

"Don't."

Caleb stopped.

Pike stared at the ledger.

"I didn't know my name was in there."

"How much did Mercer pay you?"

Pike looked at him.

"Enough."

"For what?"

Pike's jaw tightened.

"For the same thing your father did."

Caleb's voice became cold.

"You led men here."

Pike laughed bitterly.

"I was nineteen."

"You knew what you were doing."

"I knew I was being paid."

"That's the difference?"

Pike looked at him.

"You think you're better than me?"

Caleb shook his head.

"No."

Pike seemed surprised.

Caleb continued.

"I think you're worse because you had the chance to learn."

Pike's expression hardened.

He lifted his gun.

A rifle shot came from outside.

One of Pike's men fell.

Then another.

Warriors appeared on the ridge.

Nahkai had followed them after all.

The cabin erupted into chaos.

Taya fired.

Caleb tackled Pike.

The two men crashed through the doorway.

They rolled down the rocky slope.

Pike struck Caleb across the face.

Caleb punched him.

Pike drew a knife.

Caleb caught his wrist.

For a moment they struggled.

Then Pike whispered:

"Your father begged."

Caleb froze.

Pike smiled.

"I was there when he died."

Something inside Caleb broke.

He struck Pike hard enough to send him against a rock.

Pike dropped the knife.

Caleb stood over him.

His hand moved toward his revolver.

Pike looked up.

"Do it."

Caleb raised the gun.

Pike waited.

Caleb thought of his father.

He thought of the thirty-seven dead.

He thought of his mother.

He thought of Taya.

Then he lowered the gun.

"No."

Pike stared.

Caleb stepped away.

"I'm not my father."

Pike laughed.

"You're exactly like him."

Caleb looked back.

"No."

He pointed toward the ledger.

"I'm going to finish what he started."

 The Ledger

They returned to the camp before dawn.

Pike was tied to a tree.

Three of his men were dead.

The others had surrendered.

But the ledger was damaged.

Several pages had been torn away.

Caleb spread what remained on a blanket.

Taya sat beside him.

Nahkai stood behind them.

"Can you read it?"

Caleb nodded.

"Most of it."

The entries were precise.

Dates.

Payments.

Names.

Orders.

Land transfers.

The raid twenty years ago was only one entry among dozens.

There had been other valleys.

Other families.

Other communities.

All removed under false claims of military necessity.

And behind the raids was a network of men who profited from the land afterward.

At the center of it was Colonel Elias Mercer.

But there was another name.

Judge Samuel Whitcomb.

Caleb recognized it.

Whitcomb was the current federal judge in the nearest major settlement.

Taya looked at him.

"Can he help?"

Caleb shook his head.

"If his name is in this ledger, he won't."

Nahkai studied the pages.

"There is another name."

Caleb pointed.

"Governor Hale."

Nahkai nodded.

"Then this goes deeper."

Caleb looked at the ledger.

"Yes."

A young warrior approached.

"Nahkai."

The chief turned.

"Pike's men are gone."

Caleb stood.

"All of them?"

The warrior nodded.

"Except Pike."

Caleb walked toward the prisoner.

Pike looked exhausted.

"You should have killed me."

Caleb crouched.

"Who is coming?"

Pike said nothing.

"How many?"

Silence.

Caleb leaned closer.

"Mercer?"

Pike smiled.

"He's older now."

"Is he alive?"

"Yes."

"Where?"

Pike looked toward the east.

"Blackwater."

Caleb's eyes narrowed.

"Why?"

"Because that's where the land office is."

Taya stepped forward.

"He's going to register the valley."

Pike nodded.

"Tomorrow."

Caleb stood.

They had one day.

One day to get the ledger to someone who could act.

But the problem was bigger than paperwork.

Mercer had men.

Money.

Political connections.

And the law on his side.

Caleb looked at Nahkai.

"We need to go to Blackwater."

Nahkai nodded.

Taya immediately said:

"I'm coming."

"No."

She stared at him.

"No?"

"You'll be safer here."

She laughed.

"After everything that's happened, you still think I'm going to sit in camp?"

Caleb almost smiled.

"Fair point."

Nahkai approached them.

"Taya will go."

Caleb looked surprised.

"My daughter knows the land better than anyone."

Taya smiled.

"Finally."

They prepared to leave.

Pike watched.

Before Caleb mounted, the prisoner called his name.

"Blackthorn."

Caleb turned.

Pike's voice was quieter.

"I lied about your father."

Caleb stared.

"What?"

"I said he begged."

Caleb waited.

"He didn't."

Pike looked down.

"Your father stood."

Silence.

"He knew he was going to die."

Caleb's eyes narrowed.

"What happened?"

"Mercer's men caught him."

Pike swallowed.

"Isaac told them where the ledger was."

Caleb's face changed.

"They knew?"

"He lied."

Pike smiled faintly.

"He sent them to the wrong place."

Caleb understood.

"He protected it."

"Yes."

"Why didn't you tell me?"

Pike shrugged.

"Didn't seem important."

Caleb looked at him.

"It should have."

Pike lowered his eyes.

For the first time, Caleb saw something other than cruelty in the man.

He saw shame.

It did not excuse anything.

But it explained something.

Some men became monsters because they were born cruel.

Others became monsters one choice at a time.

Pike had chosen.

And so had Caleb.

That was what made all the difference.

They rode east.

The journey took most of the day.

News in the same category

“If This Is the Price, I’ll Pay It,” He Said — But Something in His Eyes Stopped Her

7 Part