In a courtroom full of adults who had already decided what to believe, six-year-old Emily walked up to her handcuffed father and drew a red heart on his cheek. Her mother called him a monster.

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The hearing paused. Nobody called the heart evidence, and nobody unlocked Michael's wrists because a child loved him. There would be recordings to request, accounts to compare and difficult questions to answer. For the first time, though, those questions were being asked. Emily stood beside him until someone brought her a chair. Michael kept his cheek turned slightly toward her. He did not want the small red heart to rub away before he could finally take her hand without a chain between them.

The adjournment lasted seventeen minutes. Michael measured it by the small clock above the door and by the number of times Paul Bennett checked his notes without turning a page. He was not permitted to follow Emily into the witness room. A family services worker had arrived, introduced herself as Nadia Price, and asked whether Emily wanted water or a quieter place to sit. Emily had looked to Michael before answering, a habit that had once made him proud and now frightened him. A child should not have needed permission to be comfortable. He had told her she could choose. She chose water, the rabbit-shaped eraser in Nadia's pencil case, and a seat from which she could see the courtroom door.

Paul returned with two photographs of the envelope, a hurried inventory and an expression Michael could not read. He had spent four weeks teaching himself not to search his lawyer's face for a verdict. At their first meeting Paul had explained that a defense was a process of proving and testing facts, not a sequence of dramatic discoveries. Michael had agreed and then asked every few minutes if Paul believed him. Today he kept the question to himself.

"The paper appears to be a service receipt," Paul said. "From the garage camera company. Three days before the incident. Somebody requested that the unit be disconnected. The name on the receipt isn't legible in the photograph, and the original may have another page. We need the vendor's records."

"Rachel told the police the camera had broken months ago."

"I know what she told them. We must find out whether that's what happened. And we need the neighbor's footage before it overwrites."

Michael lifted his joined hands and rubbed one thumb against the other. He had repaired the garage light the weekend before his arrest, balancing on a stepladder while Emily handed him screws from a biscuit tin. There had been a camera over the door then. He remembered its little green indicator, and he remembered Rachel complaining about the light it cast into the bedroom window. He had not thought of the camera as evidence because evidence belonged to courtrooms and crimes. He had thought of it as one more appliance in a house he paid to maintain.

"What about Emily?"

Paul looked up. "The court has to protect her from becoming an investigator in her parents' dispute. Nadia will talk with her about immediate safety. Anything she might be asked later needs to be handled by qualified people, with care about how the questions are put."

"Rachel will tell her she betrayed her."

"That concern belongs on the record. You don't have to carry it alone."

It was not a promise of rescue. Michael recognized the difference and was grateful. His trouble had begun with promises that sounded complete: a police officer's assurance that the confusion would be cleared up in an hour; a relative's insistence that Rachel must have misunderstood something; a neighbor's certainty that respectable families did not end up in court. Each confident sentence had collapsed under the next fact. Paul offered work, and work had edges Michael could see.

When court resumed, the judge did not order an instant release. She instructed the parties to preserve the service document, directed the prosecution to make prompt inquiries into the recordings and set a short review hearing. Rachel's lawyer objected to the implication that the envelope was trustworthy. The judge agreed that its significance had not been determined. She also said the defense's request could not be dismissed merely because the source was a child. Michael listened to both statements. At the start of the morning he would have heard only the first as defeat. Now the second mattered too.

He caught a glimpse of Emily waiting beyond the glass. The red heart on his cheek had dried into a dark little shape. He was taken through a side door before he could wave. The last thing he saw was his daughter sitting upright with both feet off the floor, her hands folded around a paper cup she was not drinking from.

At the detention center, the intake officer asked whether he wanted a cloth to wash the marker away. Michael said no. The officer shrugged and handed him his property list. In the mirror above the sink, the heart looked less like a decoration than a question. It was small enough to cover with a thumb. He thought of Emily drawing carefully while an entire room watched and wondered who had taught her that love needed visible proof. He had taught her to draw the shape, certainly. He hoped he had not taught her the rest.

News in the same category

In a courtroom full of adults who had already decided what to believe, six-year-old Emily walked up to her handcuffed father and drew a red heart on his cheek. Her mother called him a monster.

45 Part