“IN OAKDALE, I'M THE LAW!” AN ARROGANT POLICE OFFICER ARRESTED A BLACK MAN WEARING AN EXPENSIVE SUIT—BUT WENT PALE WHEN HIS PARTNER OPENED THE MAN'S IDENTIFICATION

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

As the review moved into its second week, the interviews widened. The captain spoke to dispatchers, who described the radio traffic from Elmwood Terrace as tense but controlled after Harris intervened, and who confirmed that no supervisor had been requested until the stop was effectively over, a detail that mattered because it showed how quickly the escalation had happened and how little outside help had been sought while it was happening. He spoke to the sergeant who had supervised Cole's shift on the day of the stop, who said Cole had been tired, having worked overtime the previous week, and who admitted, when pressed, that tiredness explained nothing and excused nothing, and that he had not checked in with Cole that day as closely as he might have. He spoke to officers who had patrolled with Cole and who described, with varying degrees of candor, a young officer who was good at the job when he slowed down and who struggled when he felt challenged, especially by drivers who knew their rights and said so calmly, which Cole sometimes experienced as defiance rather than as information. One officer, speaking carefully, said Cole had once told him, after a stop that had gone badly, that he felt the department expected him to be in control of every encounter and that losing control felt like failing. The captain wrote that sentence down and underlined it, because it captured something the file alone could not: a young officer who had confused control with authority, and a department that had never quite taught him the difference.

The culture question returned, in the later interviews, to the phrase itself and to what it had cost. Officers were asked, not as an accusation but as a question about their own working lives, what it meant in Oakdale to be the law, and their answers revealed a department split not between good officers and bad ones but between two understandings of the same job. For some, being the law meant being the person who arrived when nobody else would, who stood between a frightened caller and a dangerous situation, who made decisions quickly and lived with them. For others, and Cole was the clearest example, it had come to mean something narrower and more brittle: that the officer's word at the roadside was final, that questioning it was disrespect, and that backing down, even to follow procedure, was a loss of standing. Harris, when asked the same question, answered without hesitation and without rhetoric. Being the law, he said, meant being bound by it more tightly than the people you policed, not less. The review quoted him on that point, because it was the standard against which the stop would be measured, and because it came from inside the department rather than from a federal report, which made it harder to dismiss.

Cole's own interview was the longest and the most carefully handled, because the review was determined to be fair to him and also determined not to let fairness become evasion. He came in with a representative, sat upright, and answered in a voice that was steadier than it had been on Elmwood Terrace, though the twitchy energy was still there, in his hands and in the way his pale blue eyes moved across the room. He did not deny the escalation. He said he had believed the stop was lawful in its beginning, that he had believed the driver was being evasive, and that he had let frustration build when his instructions were questioned. He said he had not intended to violate anyone's rights, and the review believed him on that point, because intent and effect are different things and because a young officer can act unlawfully without setting out to break the law. He said he had been thinking about the written reprimand, about the sense that another complaint would end his career, and that the pressure had made him more rigid rather than more careful, a paradox the review noted with some sympathy and without accepting it as an excuse. When asked about the trunk, he said he had been about to order it opened, that he had believed he had grounds, and that Harris stepping in had stopped him from making a mistake he would not have been able to undo. He did not blame Harris. He said, after a pause, that Harris had saved him from himself that day, and that he had not thanked him properly, and that he was sorry for the stop in a way that went beyond worrying about his own record. The review recorded the apology without comment, because apologies are not findings, but it also recorded that Cole had shown, in that room, a capacity for self-recognition that had been absent at the roadside, and that capacity would matter to whatever came next, though what came next was not the review's to decide.

News in the same category

“IN OAKDALE, I'M THE LAW!” AN ARROGANT POLICE OFFICER ARRESTED A BLACK MAN WEARING AN EXPENSIVE SUIT—BUT WENT PALE WHEN HIS PARTNER OPENED THE MAN'S IDENTIFICATION

45 Part