But Dolores, who had directed the gospel choir at Mount Calvary for twenty-two years, noticed something in the quiet of the night. When Benjamin was asleep, he would hum. They were not random, child-like melodies. They were Clara’s songs. He hummed the exact tunes she used to sing, note for note and breath for breath, as though his mother's voice had crawled inside his chest and refused to leave. Dolores knew the difference between a child who could carry a tune and one who carried something rare.
She took a bus to a pawn shop on East 131st Street and bought a second-hand electronic keyboard for forty dollars. It was a battered thing, missing three keys: C-sharp, F, and B-flat. Benjamin taught himself to play around the gaps. He developed a fingering style so erratic and unusual that trained musicians would later stop and stare in disbelief.
For seven years, he never had a single lesson. Everything he knew came from the fading memory of his mother's voice and the unyielding patience of a grandmother who believed in him when the world didn't even know he was there.
In Garfield Heights, harboring a dream like Benjamin's was a quick way to get laughed at, so he kept his head down and his mouth shut. But Dolores had other plans.
She spotted a crumpled flyer pinned to a bulletin board at the local grocery store. American Prodigy, a nationally televised talent competition, was holding open auditions in Cleveland. The entry fee was thirty-five dollars. To some, it was pocket change; in the Norton household, it was a mountain.
Dolores went to work. She baked sweet potato pies and dense pound cakes, packing them into aluminum foil and selling them in the church lobby for three consecutive Sundays. When she finally counted thirty-five dollars in crinkled bills and heavy coins, she brought the application home.