Karen Calls Cops on Black Teen Holding Two Bikes — Unaware He Recovered Stolen One, $1M Lawsuit

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

His face was partially turned away, but Patricia recognized his jacket.

It was Daniel Foster.

Beneath the photograph were five words:

You are not the only witness.

Patricia's hands began to shake.

She immediately called Elizabeth Bennett.

At 9:47 p.m., Elizabeth answered the call.

"Mrs. Caldwell?"

"Please don't hang up."

Elizabeth sat upright.

"What happened?"

"I need to tell you something."

"Are you safe?"

"I don't know."

"Where are you?"

"At home. Robert isn't here."

Elizabeth glanced toward the hallway.

"Tell me what's going on."

Patricia struggled to speak.

"Someone sent me a photograph of Daniel."

Elizabeth froze.

"Daniel Foster?"

"Yes. I think it was taken at the Old Mill."

"Can you send it to me?"

"I can."

"Do not delete the message. Do not forward it to anyone else. Preserve the original."

Patricia's breathing became uneven.

"Elizabeth, I think Robert knows what happened to him."

"Do you have evidence?"

"I have something else. Something Robert gave me years ago."

"What?"

"A key."

Elizabeth sat very still.

"What key?"

"Brass. It has a little plastic tag with the number seventeen."

Elizabeth looked toward the evidence photographs James had sent her earlier.

The key recovered from beneath the concrete at the Old Mill had carried the same number.

"Where is it now?"

Patricia lowered her voice.

"In my house. I kept it because I didn't know what it opened."

"Why did Robert give it to you?"

"He said it was for a storage unit. He told me never to use it."

Elizabeth's heart began to race.

"Mrs. Caldwell, I need you to stay where you are. Don't touch the key. I'll have investigators contact you."

Patricia began crying.

"I should have told someone earlier."

Elizabeth spoke firmly but gently.

"Then help us now. Tell the truth about everything you remember."

After the call ended, Elizabeth immediately contacted James.

He answered on the first ring.

"What's wrong?"

"Patricia Caldwell has a key with the number seventeen. She says Robert gave it to her years ago."

James stood up.

"Seventeen?"

"The same number as the key found at the Old Mill."

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then James said:

"Elizabeth, I think we may have found the next location."

Elizabeth looked toward the dark window.

Somewhere, perhaps inside another locked room, there might be a second collection of records.

And if Patricia was telling the truth, the key might unlock the place where Robert Caldwell had hidden the last evidence connected to Daniel Foster.

But there was one detail Elizabeth could not ignore.

The photograph sent to Patricia had been taken inside the Old Mill.

That meant someone had access to the original evidence—or had been there recently.

And whoever sent it knew exactly how much the investigation had uncovered.

The next discovery would not simply reveal what happened to Daniel.

It might finally expose the person who had spent two years making sure nobody could find him.

James arrived at Patricia Caldwell's house with two investigators shortly before midnight.

He did not approach the front door immediately. Instead, he stood beside the patrol vehicle and studied the surrounding street.

The neighborhood was quiet. A few porch lights remained on, and the occasional passing car moved slowly through the darkness.

But James had learned not to mistake silence for safety.

"Has anyone seen a vehicle leaving this property?" he asked the officer assigned to the street.

"Nothing unusual. We've had a unit watching the entrance since you called."

James nodded.

"Keep it that way."

He approached the house with another investigator. Patricia opened the door before he could knock.

Her face was pale, and her hands trembled.

"Thank you for coming."

"Are you alone?"

"Yes. Robert hasn't returned."

"Have you touched the key?"

"No. It's still where I left it."

Patricia led them into the living room.

On the coffee table sat an old wooden jewelry box. Beside it was a folded piece of paper.

James looked at the box.

"Is the key inside?"

Patricia shook her head.

"No. I put it in an envelope after I found it in Robert's desk. I didn't want to lose it."

She handed him the envelope.

James did not open it immediately. He photographed its position, noted the time, and asked the evidence technician to document the entire process.

When the envelope was opened, the brass key appeared exactly as Patricia had described.

A small plastic tag was attached to its ring.

17.

James examined it through the evidence technician's camera.

"Where did Robert say it came from?"

Patricia sat down.

"He told me it belonged to a storage unit. He said the unit contained old business records and equipment that were no longer needed."

"Did he tell you where?"

"No."

"Why did you keep it?"

"Because he was unusually serious about it. He said I should never throw it away, never give it to anyone, and never ask questions about it."

James exchanged a glance with the investigator.

"Do you remember when he gave it to you?"

News in the same category

Karen Calls Cops on Black Teen Holding Two Bikes — Unaware He Recovered Stolen One, $1M Lawsuit

45 Part