Nia was in the kitchen doing homework. She heard Karen's voice and she came to the doorway with her pencil still in her hand, and I saw her face change the way it had changed every time Karen's name had come up lately, that careful blank look she put on when she did not want anyone to see what she was feeling. I told Karen we would come. I did not want to. I wanted to close the door and go back to sleep and pretend that the rest of the street did not exist. But I had learned by then that refusing Karen only gave her a better story to tell. So I put on a clean shirt, I told Nia to bring her school bag because I did not know how long it would take, and we drove to the clubhouse in the late light, past the rows of houses that all looked the same and none of them looked like home anymore.
The room was smaller than I remembered. It was the same room where they held the summer barbecue sign-ups and the holiday decoration votes, with the folding tables pushed together and the plastic chairs lined up in rows, but that evening it felt like a courtroom that someone had forgotten to finish building. There were maybe fifteen people in there, board members and a few neighbors I recognized and a few I did not, and they were all sitting very straight, the way people sit when they have already decided something and are only waiting for the formal part to be over. Karen sat at the head of the table with her hands folded in front of her, and she looked pleased in a way she did not bother to hide. Madison was there too, sitting against the wall near the door, her arms wrapped around herself, staring at the floor. She did not look up when we came in. That told me more than anything Karen had said on the porch.
A woman I barely knew stood up first. I had seen her at the pool once or twice and at a block party two summers ago, and I could not have told you her last name if you had paid me. She had the look of someone who had been rehearsing, her hands gripping a piece of paper that shook a little when she held it up, and she cleared her throat twice before she started talking. What she said was so ugly that for a second I did not understand it at all. She said that there had been complaints. She said that people had heard things. She said that a father who bought his seventeen-year-old daughter a car like that, a car that cost more than most of the houses on the street had cost when they were built, was not behaving the way a father should behave. She said the word inappropriate and then she said it again, slower, like she wanted to make sure everyone in the room heard the shape of it. She said that Nia was a minor and that what I was doing to her, the gifts and the attention and the way I talked about her, was not normal, and that the board had a responsibility to protect the children in this neighborhood, and that I needed to be punished.
The room went very quiet. I could hear the air conditioner humming in the window and a car passing outside on the street, and I could feel Nia go rigid beside me. She was seventeen years old, a 4.0 student, the valedictorian of Willow Creek High, a girl with a full scholarship to an Ivy League school who wanted to be a doctor, and she was sitting in a plastic chair in a room full of adults while a stranger stood up and said her father was a danger to her. Her hand found mine under the table. Her fingers were cold. I held on to them and I did not let go, and I looked around the room at all those straight-backed people, and I waited until the woman had finished, until she had folded her paper and sat down, and then I stood up.