Daniel agreed.
He did not know whether the anonymous sender was a conscientious employee, a disgruntled officer, or someone trying to manipulate the investigation.
He would not assume the message was true simply because it supported his concerns.
But he would not ignore it, either.
As he placed the envelope inside his briefcase, he noticed the date again.
Six months earlier.
That was approximately when Samuel Ortiz had submitted his complaint about the altered report.
The timing might be coincidental.
Or it might be the first indication that someone inside the department had been trying to expose a problem long before Daniel became chief.
He left the office and walked toward the elevators.
This time, the reception officer stood as he approached.
"Good evening, Chief Cole."
Daniel paused.
"Good evening."
Morris looked uncomfortable.
"Sir, I owe you an apology about this morning. I didn't recognize you, and I was unnecessarily dismissive."
Daniel studied the young officer.
"Thank you for saying that."
"I should have checked the appointment properly."
"Yes, you should have."
Morris lowered his eyes.
Daniel continued in a measured voice.
"But I want you to understand something. You should not have treated me differently because I turned out to be the chief. The person you dismissed this morning could have been a witness, a victim, a family member, or an employee who needed assistance."
Morris nodded.
"I understand."
"I hope you do. The next time someone approaches the desk, follow the security procedures. Ask the questions you need to ask, verify the information, and treat the person with basic courtesy. You don't need to know someone's title to do that."
"I will, Chief."
Daniel gave him a small nod and entered the elevator.
The doors closed.
For a moment, he watched his reflection in the polished metal.
The appointment announcement would soon be everywhere. His photograph would appear on news websites, television screens, and department computers. People would speculate about his plans and predict how long he would last.
But none of that would determine whether the department changed.
The real test would come in rooms where nobody was watching, in case files that had been ignored for months, and in conversations where the easiest answer would be to protect a colleague rather than confront an uncomfortable fact.
Daniel reached the ground floor and stepped into the lobby.
Outside, the city moved through the evening rush.
Somewhere in Chicago, an officer was beginning a shift. A detective was preparing to question a witness. A family was waiting for news about a missing relative. A resident was deciding whether reporting a problem was worth the trouble.
They would never know what had happened inside headquarters that day.
They would never see the anonymous envelope or the incomplete audit records.
They would judge the department by what its officers did when they arrived at a door, stopped a vehicle, answered a question, or decided whether a complaint deserved attention.
That was where the institution's reputation was truly made.
Not in the photographs on the executive floor.
Not in the speeches delivered around polished conference tables.
Not in the name printed beneath the words Chief of Police.
It was made in the ordinary moments when people with authority decided whether to use that authority fairly.
Daniel stepped onto the sidewalk and walked toward the waiting car.
He had come to headquarters expecting a difficult first day.
He had not expected to discover that the department's most important unanswered questions might be hidden inside records that had already been marked closed.
And he had not expected that someone inside the building would risk sending him a message.
The envelope had offered a direction, not an answer.
Before he could follow it, he would need to establish who had created the files, who had reviewed them, and why the final interviews had never been completed.
He would need to hear from Samuel Ortiz.
He would need to question Lieutenant Harris.
And sooner or later, he would need to sit across from Deputy Chief Shaw and ask why the department had treated the closure of a complaint as more important than establishing what had actually happened.
Daniel looked out the car window as headquarters disappeared behind him.
He had accepted the position because he believed the department could become better.
Now he was beginning to understand how much courage that belief would require.
The next morning, the real work would begin.
The following morning, Chief Daniel Cole arrived at headquarters before sunrise, carrying the same worn leather briefcase he had brought on his first day. He had slept for barely four hours. The anonymous envelope, the missing records, and the unfinished complaints had occupied his thoughts long after he had returned home.
He knew that the flash drive might contain nothing useful. It might hold duplicate documents, irrelevant correspondence, or information deliberately arranged to mislead him. But the note inside the envelope had been unusually specific. Whoever had written it knew about complaints marked closed before final interviews were completed.
That detail was too precise to dismiss.
At seven fifteen, Daniel entered the evidence review room, where Margaret Ellis, the director of internal investigations, was waiting beside a secure workstation. A technician named Peter Lawson had already documented the envelope, photographed the contents, and prepared a forensic copy of the drive according to the department's evidence-preservation procedures.
The original device had been secured.
The examination would take place on the verified copy.
"Have you found anything?" Daniel asked.
Peter nodded toward the monitor.
"Several files. Most appear to be ordinary office documents, but three folders contain material related to complaint reviews. One folder is labeled West Division. Another contains spreadsheets listing case numbers, review dates, and closure recommendations."
"Can we verify where the files came from?"
"Not completely yet. Some documents contain metadata consistent with department systems, but that doesn't prove who created the drive or who placed the files on it. We'll need to compare them with the official records."
Daniel pulled out a chair.
"Show me what you've found."
Peter opened the first folder.
The screen displayed a spreadsheet containing twenty-three complaint numbers. Beside each number were columns labeled RECEIVED, ASSIGNED, INTERVIEW COMPLETED, SUPERVISORY REVIEW, and FINAL STATUS.
Daniel leaned forward.
Several cases had been marked closed even though the interview column remained blank.
In other cases, the supervisory review date came before the date on which the assigned investigator had recorded receiving the relevant evidence.
One entry was particularly unusual. The final status had been entered at 4:42 p.m. on a Thursday, while the investigator's notes indicated that the final witness interview had been scheduled for the following Monday.
Daniel pointed at the screen.
"Could this be a data-entry error?"
"It could," Peter answered. "A status can be entered incorrectly. Dates can also be affected by migration between systems. But we have enough discrepancies to justify checking every entry against the original case files."
Margaret opened the folder containing the complaint summaries.
"I recognize several of these numbers," she said. "They were among the cases flagged in the preliminary inventory."
"Do we know who entered the closure dates?"
"Not from this spreadsheet. The system audit records should tell us which account made each change, provided those records are complete."
Daniel looked at the list.
"Then that's our next step. I want a verified comparison between this spreadsheet and the official records. No one should be accused based on an anonymous document alone."
Peter nodded.
"I'll have the technical team begin the comparison."
As he returned to the workstation, Margaret turned toward Daniel.
"There's something else you should know. The complaint system was upgraded eighteen months ago. During the migration, some historical records were transferred into a new database. The department has previously acknowledged that a portion of the audit history was not preserved."
"How much?"
"We don't have a reliable number."
Daniel stared at her.
"How can we know whether a complaint was handled properly if we cannot establish who changed the record?"