"This is Detective Harding's initial report. Quote, 'Victim states assailant was approximately 6 ft tall, male, unknown race, wearing a black ski mask and a gray hoodie.' But today, you're certain it was my client. How can you be sure if the man's face was covered?" Kyle looked desperately toward Pierce. Pierce stood up. "Objection." "Counsel is badgering the witness, who has already positively identified the defendant." "I am not," Rachel countered.
"I am pointing out a massive contradiction in the state's primary witness." "Mr. Morton," Judge Kincaid interjected, leaning forward. "Please answer the question." "How did you identify the defendant if the robber wore a ski mask?" Kyle was sweating profusely now. He "He pulled it up for a second when he was leaving. He pulled it up and I saw his face.
Just for a second." It was a lie. A bad one. Rachel, Devon, and even Pierce knew it. But would the jury? "He pulled it up," Rachel pressed.
"Why would he do that? He's in the middle of a robbery and he decides to unmask himself?" "I don't know. He just did," Kyle shouted. "It was him. I know it was him." "Or," Rachel said, lowering her voice, "is it because Mr. Pierce here showed you a picture of my client, a single photo, not a lineup, and told you it was him?" "Objection." Pierce was on his feet, his face red.
"Counsel is making baseless, inflammatory accusations." "Sustained," Judge Kincaid barked. "Ms. Burg, you will strike that from your questioning unless you have proof. Move on or sit down." Rachel's shoulders slumped. She had no proof. Just a gut feeling and a terrified witness.