The air in Courtroom 3B of the Maricopa County Superior Court was stale, smelling of old coffee and cheap floor wax. It was a smell 19-year-old Devon Washington couldn't get out of his nose. He sat at the defense table, his oversized, ill-fitting suit—provided by his public defender—itching at his neck. He looked small, swallowed by the polished mahogany of a system that was about to digest him whole.
The prosecution called Kyle Morton to the stand.
Leland Pierce, the prosecutor, moved with the predatory grace of a shark. He was handsome in a cruel, angular way, wearing a crisp, thousand-dollar suit. He was the star of the DA's office, known for his law-and-order stance and a conviction rate that bordered on miraculous. He flashed a brilliant, toothy smile at the jury he had carefully selected: nine white, two Latino, one Asian. Not a single Black face.
Devon's public defender, Rachel Burke, scribbled frantically on a yellow legal pad. She was young, her hair pulled back in a severe bun, and she was drowning. She knew her client was innocent, but knowing it and proving it were two different universes.
Kyle Morton, a pale, twitchy twenty-year-old, shuffled to the stand. He wouldn't look at Devon.
"Mr. Morton," Pierce began, his voice like smooth honey. "Please tell the court, in your own words, what you saw on the night of August 22nd."
"I was working the night shift at the Circle K on Jefferson," Kyle swallowed hard.
"And what happened at approximately 11:30 p.m.?"
"He came in." Kyle's hand, resting on the Bible, was shaking. He made a vague gesture toward the defense table.
After a brief skirmish over the vagueness of the identification, Pierce smiled, his trap sprung. "Mr. Morton, do you see the man who robbed you in this courtroom? Please point directly at him."