Then turned east.
Thomas watched until the dust disappeared.
He felt no relief.
Men who rode that far merely to observe a house were not passing travelers.
They would return.
He checked the rifle.
Counted his ammunition.
Repaired the loose shutters.
Then sat on the porch beside Ayana.
For a long time, neither spoke.
Finally, she asked, "Why fight for me?"
Thomas looked toward the garden.
The plants moved gently in the evening breeze.
He considered the question.
Why?
Because what happened in San Ysidro was wrong.
Because he had watched too many people suffer while telling himself there was nothing he could do.
Because Ayana had brought life back to a place he had nearly abandoned.
Because he had begun caring whether she was safe.
But he did not want any of those reasons to sound like a demand for gratitude.
So he answered simply.
"Because nobody has the right to drag you away."
Ayana studied him.
Then looked toward the stars.
For the first time, she seemed willing to consider that he might mean exactly what he said.
The first attack came four nights later.
It was not a full assault.
No gunmen stormed the house.
No bullets struck the windows.
Instead, someone slipped through the south pasture after midnight and cut the gate hinges.
The cattle escaped into the hills.
Thomas discovered the damage at dawn.
He stood before the broken gate, examining the fresh marks left by a sharp tool.
Ayana approached beside him.
"Wind?"
He shook his head.
"No."
He pointed toward the hinge.
"Cut."
She crouched.
Touched the metal.
Then looked toward the eastern ridge.
"The riders."
"Probably."
Thomas felt anger rise.
His herd was small.
Only twelve cattle and four young steers.
Losing even a few could threaten his ability to purchase winter feed.
The men responsible understood that.
They had chosen a way to hurt him without entering the yard.
Ayana stood.
"We find them."
Thomas looked at her.
"The cattle?"
She nodded.
"Tracks are fresh."
He considered.
Then fetched Boone.
They spent the morning searching the surrounding hills.
Ayana proved astonishingly skilled at reading the ground.
She noticed broken grass.
Loose stones.
Faint hoofprints nearly invisible to Thomas.
At one point, the tracks divided near a dry creek.
Thomas frowned.
"Which way?"
Ayana examined the soil.
Then pointed north.
"Most went there."
"How can you tell?"
She showed him a cluster of impressions.
He studied them.
Then nodded.
"You're right."
They followed the trail into a shallow valley.
By noon, they found six cattle grazing beneath a stand of juniper trees.
Thomas rounded them up while Ayana searched farther east.
She returned twenty minutes later.
"More."
They recovered four additional animals before sunset.
Two remained missing.
Thomas suspected they had wandered toward the high timber.
He knew finding them would require another day.
As they returned, he looked toward Ayana.
"You saved me a good deal of money today."
She stiffened.
He immediately regretted the wording.
"I mean the cattle."
She looked away.
Thomas continued.
"You didn't have to come."
Ayana glanced toward him.
"I wanted to."
He nodded.
"Then thank you."
She studied his face.
For a moment, something softened.
Then she smiled faintly.
"You're welcome."
They returned to the ranch exhausted.
Thomas prepared beans and coffee.
Ayana tended the garden.
The evening passed quietly.
But Thomas knew the sabotage was a warning.
The men looking for Ayana wanted him frightened.
Poor.
Unable to defend his property.
Perhaps desperate enough to surrender her.
He had already spent his savings.
Now they were trying to destroy his livelihood.
That night, Thomas sat beside the fireplace examining his remaining money.
Four dollars and thirty cents.
Enough for a few supplies.
Not enough for winter feed.
He stared at the coins.
Then looked toward Martha's photograph.
He felt the old fear returning.
Not fear of death.
Fear of failing someone who depended on him.
But before the thought could become another spiral of guilt, Ayana entered.
She carried a small basket.
Inside were beans from the first plants in her garden.
Only a handful.
But healthy.
Green.
Alive.
She placed them on the table.
Thomas looked up.
"Already?"
Ayana nodded.
"First harvest."
He examined the beans.
Then smiled.
"Well, I'll be."
She sat opposite him.
For a while, they looked at the small basket.
Then Thomas spoke.
"They cut the gate because they want me to give up."
Ayana nodded.
"I know."
He looked toward the window.
"They may come again."
"I know."
Thomas hesitated.
"You could still leave."
Her expression hardened.
He raised one hand.
"I'm not telling you to."
She watched him.
"I'm saying you have the choice."
For a long moment, Ayana remained silent.
Then she pushed the basket toward him.
"What does that mean?" he asked.
She looked directly at him.
"Beans grow here."
Thomas nodded.
"Yes."
"I planted them."
"Yes."
She paused.
"Then I choose to stay until they are ready."
Thomas stared.
The answer was simple.
Yet it meant more than a grand declaration could have.
Ayana was not staying because Thomas had paid for her.
Not because he demanded work.
Not because she had nowhere else to go.
She was staying because she had begun making choices again.
He nodded.
"All right."
They ate the beans that evening.
Thomas declared them the finest vegetables ever grown in New Mexico Territory.
Ayana informed him that he had very poor judgment.
He laughed.
And for a few brief minutes, neither thought about the men watching from the eastern hills.
Marshal Daniel Mercer answered Thomas's letter eleven days after it was sent.
A rider delivered the envelope shortly after noon.
Thomas recognized the government seal immediately.
He carried the letter into the cabin and broke it open beside the kitchen window.
Ayana watched from the table.
He read silently.
Then read it again.