Vance hit the tree with a sickening thud, slid down the bark into the dirt, and lay completely unconscious, his breathing ragged and shallow.
Silence returned to the creek.
Mateo stood panting heavily, his chest heaving, his fists dripping with water and mud. He immediately dropped to his knees in the creek bed, his hands frantically searching the muddy water for the roll of papers Vance had dropped.
"Mateo! Look!" Ayana called out softly.
She was kneeling on the bank three feet away. She held the yellowed papers in her hands.
The wet mud had extinguished the small flame before it could burn more than an inch of the margin. The ink was slightly smeared, but every single wordâhis fatherâs letter, the 1858 treaty, the signatures, and the forged survey mapâwas completely intact, readable, and undamaged.
Mateo let out a long, ragged sob of relief, sinking back onto his heels in the shallow water.
Ayana walked into the creek, kneeling beside him in the mud. She reached out, wrapping her arms around his neck, pulling his wet face against her shoulder.
Mateo wrapped his arms around her waist, holding her tight against his chest, feeling the steady, strong beat of her heart against his ribs.
"We have them," Ayana whispered into his ear, her voice thick with emotion. "We have the proof, Mateo. Itâs over."
Mateo pulled back slightly, looking into her beautiful, bronze face, his hands gently framing her jawline. "You saved my life, Ayana. You saved everything."
Ayana looked down at the heavy Colt revolver she was still holding in her right hand, offering a quiet, amused smirk. "I told you I could shoot if they got closer than ten feet."
Mateo couldn't help itâhe threw his head back and laughed, a loud, clear, joyful sound that echoed through the mountain pine trees, washing away fourteen years of darkness and shadow.
He stood up, helping her out of the creek, and gathered their horses.
"Vance and Miller will live," Mateo said, looking at the two groaning men lying in the dirt. "Tie them to those trees with their own lassos. We ride straight to Santa Fe."
The territorial capital of Santa Fe was a bustling, sun-baked city of adobe plazas, brick government buildings, wooden boardwalks, and crowded streets filled with freight wagons, U.S. Army cavalry patrols, and Mexican merchants.
It was mid-morning on the fourth day when Mateo and Ayana rode their trail-weary horses up the main street toward the Federal Courthouse.
They looked like two ghosts emerging from the wilderness. Their clothes were caked with red desert dust and mountain mud, their faces sun-scorched, their eyes rimmed with red fatigue. But they rode side by side, their posture proud and straight, attracting curious stares from townspeople walking along the covered boardwalks.
They dismounted outside the two-story red brick building that housed the Territorial District Court.
Mateo tied the horses to the hitching post, checked the leather pouch tucked safely inside his wool vest, and turned to Ayana. "You ready for this?"
Ayana adjusted her dark wool scarf over her shoulders, her chin held high. "I have waited fourteen years for this morning, Mateo. Lead the way."
They walked up the wide stone steps, pushed open the double oak doors, and stepped into the cool, marble-floored hallway of the courthouse.
A young bailiff wearing a brass-buttoned vest stopped them near the courtroom doors, his eyebrows raised in suspicion at their dusty appearance. "Can I help you folks? The court is in executive session today."
"I need to see Federal Judge Samuel Brooks," Mateo said, his voice quiet, deep, and carrying an absolute, undeniable authority.
"The Judge is preparing a land hearing," the bailiff said, shaking his head. "He can't be disturbedâ"
"Tell him Mateo Reyes is standing in his hallway," Mateo interrupted, stepping closer to the young man. "Tell him Iâve brought Diego Reyesâs original 1858 survey plates and the treaty signed by Nahtan."
The bailiffâs eyes went wide as saucers. He looked from Mateoâs dirt-caked face to Ayana's solemn features, swallowed hard, turned on his heel, and hurried through the heavy oak doors into the courtroom.
Thirty seconds later, the oak doors swung wide open.
An elderly man stepped out into the hallway. He was tall, dressed in a sharp black suit, with thick silver hair and sharp, intelligent blue eyes framed by wire-rimmed spectacles. He carried a heavy wooden cane, but his posture was straight as a pine tree.
Judge Samuel Brooks stared across the marble floor at Mateo.
"Mateo?" the old judge whispered, his voice trembling with disbelief. "My God... you look just like your father."
Mateo walked forward, taking off his hat. "Judge Brooks. Itâs been a long time."
Judge Brooks looked at Ayana standing beside him, his sharp eyes taking in her buckskin dress and proud stance. "And you... you are Nahtanâs daughter."
"Ayana," she said softly, offering a respectful nod.
Judge Brooks let out a long, heavy breath, gesturing toward his private chambers down the hall. "Come inside. Close the doors. Tell me what has happened in Valverde."
For the next forty-five minutes, sitting in the judge's mahogany-paneled office surrounded by leather-bound law books, Mateo and Ayana laid out the entire story.
They placed the rusted brass key, the oilcloth map, the forged survey plates, and Diego Reyes's final letter onto the judgeâs polished desk.
Judge Brooks put on his spectacles, picking up Diegoâs letter with trembling fingers. As he read his old friend's dying words, his face turned from pale surprise to a deep, dark, terrifying judicial fury.
He reached the end of the letter, set it down gently, and looked up at Mateo.
"Diego came to this office fourteen years ago," Judge Brooks said softly, his voice thick with old emotion. "He told me he suspected Creed was altering survey markers. Two weeks later, I heard he had died in a riding accident. I searched the territorial land registry, but I could find no record of the joint agreement. Without the paper, my hands were tied."
The old judge slammed his heavy fist down onto his mahogany desk with a thunderous crack!
"Silas Creed has built an empire on blood, forgery, and murder!" Judge Brooks declared, his blue eyes flashing like cold steel. "He thought he could buy the land office and bury the truth in a dry wash! He was wrong!"
Judge Brooks pulled a sheet of official territorial parchment from his drawer, dipped his fountain pen into black ink, and began writing with furious speed.
"Bailiff!" the judge roared toward the open door.
The young bailiff ran into the office. "Yes, Your Honor!"
"Take this federal bench warrant directly to United States Marshal Thomas Vance at the federal armory!" Judge Brooks commanded, slapping the signed paper into the young man's hand. "Tell him to assemble a posse of twenty armed deputies immediately! We ride for the C Bar Syndicate at sunset!"
The sun was sinking below the western horizons when a force of twenty-five mounted men rode through the grand timber gates of the C Bar Syndicate ranch headquarters.
At the head of the column rode U.S. Marshal Thomas Vanceâa broad-chested man with a silver star pinned to his buckskin vestâflanked by Mateo Reyes, Ayana, and Judge Samuel Brooks riding in a black leather buggy.
Behind them rode fifteen heavily armed federal deputies and eight Apache warriors led by Chato, who had ridden north to join the federal posse at the river crossing.
The C Bar headquarters was a massive, luxurious estateâa two-story stone manor house, three large wooden barns, a blacksmith shop, and bunkhouses capable of housing forty men.
As the posse pulled up into the stone courtyard, two dozen C Bar cowhands spilled out of the bunkhouses, their hands resting on their holstered revolvers, their faces tight with confusion and anger.
The front oak doors of the stone manor house swung open.
Silas Creed stepped out onto the wide stone porch.
He was sixty years old, heavy-set, wearing a fine black wool suit, a silk cravat, a gold pocket watch chain stretched across his vest, and a wide-brimmed beaver hat. His silver hair was neatly combed, his face smooth-shaven, his posture that of a king inspecting his domain.
He looked at the armed posse standing in his yard, his eyes settling on Mateo Reyes and Ayana. A subtle, dangerous shadow flickered across his face, but he instantly forced a grand, welcoming smile onto his lips.
"Marshal Vance!" Creed called out, his voice smooth as honey, stepping down the stone stairs. "What brings the United States Marshals to my ranch on such a fine evening? And with such... colorful company?"
Marshal Vance reined in his horse ten feet from Creed, pulling a folded paper from his pocket. "Silas Creed. I have a federal warrant for your arrest, issued by Territorial Judge Samuel Brooks."
Creedâs smile froze. "An arrest warrant? On what charge, Marshal? This must be some absurd misunderstandingâ"
"The charges," Judge Brooks barked, stepping down from his buggy with the help of his cane, "are grand land fraud, forgery of territorial survey plates, conspiracy to commit murder, and the first-degree murder of Diego Reyes fourteen years ago!"
A shocked murmur rippled through the gathered C Bar cowboys. Several of the younger hands took a step backward, away from Creed.
Creedâs face turned from smooth charm to an ugly, dark crimson. "Thatâs a lie! Diego Reyes died in a riding accident! That was proven fourteen years ago!"
Mateo urged Copper forward three paces, stepping out in front of the posse.
He reached into his saddlebag, pulled out the yellowed sheet of paper, and held it high above his head in the fading sunlight.
"My father left a letter, Creed!" Mateo shouted, his voice echoing off the stone walls of the manor house. "He left it in a sealed tube beneath the floorboards of the old line shack! He wrote your name! He wrote how you threatened him, how you forged the survey plates, and how you promised to kill him if he went to Santa Fe!"