I heard about the visits to Ryan's apartment the way you hear about most things in an evaluation, which is to say sideways, weeks later, in a sentence Laura read me off a summary while she was looking for a different page. Ruiz had gone to Ryan's apartment twice. The first time, the report said, the home was immaculate, the snacks were arranged, a framed photograph of Ella stood on the bookshelf, and Ryan had been warm and fluent and heartbroken in all the right places. He had told Ruiz that Ella was the center of his world. He had told her that Megan had poisoned the child against him, that he only wanted what every father wants, that he was not a perfect man but he was a present one.
Then Ruiz had asked him the small questions, the ones nobody rehearses for. What was Ella reading right now. He said she loved the dog books, the ones with the dog on the cover, which had been true in first grade. Ella had finished those two years ago; she was reading a book about a girl who sails around an island with a horse, and she was reading it slowly on purpose because she did not want it to end. Who was Ella's teacher this year. He said Mrs. — and stopped, and laughed a little, and said the names ran together, the school changed them around so much. Ella's teacher was Ms. Okafor, who had taught her for two years running because the school looped the classes, and who sent home a newsletter every Friday that Ryan was copied on. What did Ella eat when she was upset, what was she afraid of, what was the name of her best friend, what had the pediatrician said at her last visit. He answered the way a man answers questions about a country he has visited and loved and never lived in. He knew the famous things. He did not know the Tuesdays.
I want to be careful about this, because I am not a fair narrator where Ryan is concerned, and the report was not cruel about it, and I have tried not to be crueler than the report. He was not a monster in those pages. He cried once, Ruiz wrote, talking about Ella's birth, and she believed the tears. He kept her baby blanket folded in a drawer. What he did not have was the knowledge that comes from being the one who is there for the unremarkable hours, because he had arranged his life so that someone else was always there for those, and the someone else had been me. He loved his daughter the way a man loves the idea of winning her: entirely, and as a verdict on himself. The wanting was real. It was the knowing that had never been asked of him, and so he had never built it, and an eight-year-old cannot eat wanting for dinner.
Ruiz also observed Ella with Ryan, on one of his weekends, for two hours in the middle of a Saturday. I knew about that visit in advance and I spent it cleaning my already clean kitchen and hating the whole architecture of a process that required my daughter to be watched in her father's home like a specimen of the truth. What came back to me, again sideways and again in summary, was not damning, and I have tried to hold it at the size it actually was. Ella had been glad to see him. She had run the balcony. She had shown Ruiz the guest room that was called her room, with the bedspread she had not chosen and the shelf of toys that stayed there, some of them still in the age range below the girl she currently was. She had been, the report said, delightful and cooperative and noticeably older than eight — a small, polished hostess in her father's apartment, offering the guest a juice box, asking the guest about her car, performing daughterhood with a competence that Ruiz, who had watched her sprawl on my couch arguing that bedtime was a form of tyranny, noted without comment and therefore with a great deal of comment. Twice she had asked what time it was. Once she had asked whether she could call me, and Ryan had said, "We're having our time now, El," and she had said, "Okay," in a voice Ruiz described as practiced. When Ruiz asked her, at the end, what she and her dad did together, Ella said, "We watch movies and he orders the food I like," and when Ruiz asked what happened at his apartment when she was sad, Ella said, "I wait until it's not so big," and could not say, when asked gently, who helped it get smaller.