Actually, sir, he said, "we installed an additional camera yesterday at your mother's request."
Nathaniel stared at him.
Then get it, he said.
As Marcus hurried away, the terrace fell into a silence I had never heard before in a room full of people. It was not the polite silence of guests waiting for a speech. It was the heavy, held-breath silence of hundreds of people who had just watched something terrible happen and did not know what to do next. The music had stopped. The waiters had stopped moving. Even the city below seemed quieter, as if Manhattan itself were listening.
Eleanor was still on the ground, her back against the low stone wall, her dress torn at the shoulder, her silver hair loose and tangled. A woman in a pale blue gown knelt beside her, offering a shawl, and another guest brought a glass of water, but Eleanor did not seem to notice them. Her eyes were on me. She reached for my wrist, her fingers closing around it, and her fingers were ice cold, colder than I expected, as if the wind eighty-two floors up had gone straight through her.
Your name, she whispered, and her voice was so quiet that I had to lean closer to hear her. "Rose Carter."
Her eyes widened, as if she had just remembered something, or as if something she had known for a long time had suddenly come back to her, sharp and clear.
Carter? she said.
Yes, ma'am, I said, and I knelt beside her, because my legs were shaking and I did not trust myself to stand. "Rose Carter."
Was your mother's name Grace? she asked.
My stomach tightened. My mother. Grace Carter. I had not heard her name spoken by a stranger in years, not since the funeral, not since the fire, and hearing it here, on this rooftop, from this woman I had met only an hour ago, felt like being struck.
Yes, I said, slowly. "Grace Carter. She died when I was twelve."
Eleanor made a small, broken sound, somewhere between a gasp and a sob, and her hand tightened around my wrist.
Nathaniel turned toward us, his face pale, his brow furrowed, and he knelt on Eleanor's other side, his hand on her shoulder.
Mom? What is it? he asked. "What are you talking about?"
Before she could answer, Marcus returned, moving quickly through the crowd, a tablet in his hands, his expression grave. He stopped beside Nathaniel and held the tablet out, and the screen glowed in the dim light of the terrace, and everyone near us leaned in, trying to see.
Sir, Marcus said, "you need to see this."
He played the recording.
On the small screen, the terrace looked different, smaller, flatter, but unmistakable. I could see Eleanor sitting near the railing, her silver cane against her knee. I could see Victoria approaching her, her ivory dress bright even on the screen, her movements smooth and unhurried. They exchanged several words. I could not hear them yet, but I could see Eleanor shake her head, once, firmly, and I could see Victoria lean closer, and then, clearly, terribly clearly, I could see Victoria grab Eleanor's shoulders with both hands and shove.
Eleanor's body went backward over the railing. Victoria stepped back, her hands still outstretched, and for a second she simply stood there, watching, before she raised her hands to her face and began to cry.
The terrace fell silent again, deeper this time, a silence that felt like a held breath that would never be released.
Nathaniel watched the footage twice. He did not speak. He did not look at Victoria. His face was still, and his hands were steady on the tablet, and when the recording ended the second time, he set the tablet down carefully on the stone, as if it were something fragile, and he looked up.
That's enough, he said.
Victoria stepped backward, her hands out in front of her, her voice pleading now, high and fast.
Nathaniel, listen to me, she said. "Please, just listen to me. I can explain. It wasn't what it looked like. She was going to say something, she was going to ruin everything, and I—"
He didn't look at her. He looked at his mother, and then at me, and then at Marcus, and his voice, when he spoke, was low and controlled, the voice of a man holding himself together by force of will.
Marcus cleared his throat.
Sir, he said, "there's audio."
The recording continued, and this time the sound came through the tablet's small speaker, thin and tinny, but clear enough for everyone near us to hear. Victoria's voice, sharp and frightened, filled the silence.
You promised nobody would ever find out what happened to Grace Carter!
My blood turned cold.
Grace Carter.
My mother.
I felt the terrace tilt beneath me, and the chandeliers seemed to blur, and the white roses on the tables lost their colour, and all I could hear was my mother's name, spoken by a woman I had never met before tonight, in a voice full of fear and threat.
Nathaniel stared at Victoria, his face white, his eyes wide, and when he spoke, his voice was barely above a whisper.
What did you do to Rose's mother? he asked.
Victoria looked toward the elevator, her eyes darting, her hands clutching at her dress, and I could see her calculating, weighing whether she could run, whether the doors would open in time, whether anyone would stop her.
Eleanor suddenly shouted, her voice stronger than I had thought possible, cutting through the silence like a bell.