She was not Olivia's biological daughter.
But the testing indicated a close biological relationship between Lucy and Sophie.
Catherine leaned forward.
“What kind of relationship?”
The genetic specialist's report identified a likely first-cousin relationship, subject to confirmation through additional family testing.
Nathan stared.
“A cousin?”
Olivia looked confused.
“How?”
Nathan had only one brother.
Daniel.
And Daniel had no children outside his marriage, as far as Nathan knew.
But the resemblance between Sophie and Lucy was striking.
And the genetic relationship suggested a connection neither family understood.
Detective Carter called Daniel for an interview.
He arrived looking worried.
Nathan showed him the photograph.
Daniel stared.
“Who is that?”
“Lucy.”
Daniel shook his head.
“I don't know her.”
Nathan watched him carefully.
“Are you sure?”
Daniel looked offended.
“Of course I'm sure.”
Carter asked whether Daniel had ever participated in fertility treatment, sperm donation, or any other arrangement that might explain a biological relationship.
Daniel stared.
“No.”
Then he hesitated.
Nathan noticed.
“What?”
Daniel looked down.
“Years ago, Emma and I tried fertility treatment.”
Nathan frowned.
“I know.”
Daniel swallowed.
“We used a private clinic.”
“Which clinic?”
Daniel looked toward Carter.
“Bennett Family Medical.”
Silence.
Nathan felt cold.
Their father's foundation had financed that clinic.
Daniel explained that he and Emma had undergone fertility treatment eight years earlier.
The clinic collected and stored reproductive samples.
The treatment was unsuccessful.
They eventually stopped trying.
Two years later, Emma became pregnant naturally.
They now had a son.
Daniel believed the clinic had destroyed the unused samples.
But he had never received independent confirmation.
Carter wrote everything down.
“Do you have the paperwork?”
Daniel nodded.
“At home.”
Nathan stared at his brother.
“Did Dad arrange the clinic?”
Daniel looked uncomfortable.
“He recommended it.”
Nathan closed his eyes.
Of course he had.
Investigators began reviewing the clinic's historical records.
They discovered that several storage logs were missing.
Some donor files had been reassigned.
And a former laboratory director had received substantial payments from a company controlled by Richard Bennett.
The records suggested unauthorized use of reproductive material.
But investigators needed additional evidence before drawing conclusions about Lucy's parentage.
Meanwhile, police located Lucy's guardian.
Her name was Hannah Price.
She was thirty-eight.
She worked as a librarian in Connecticut.
Hannah had adopted Lucy through a private placement arrangement shortly after the child's birth.
She believed the adoption was legitimate.
When investigators contacted her, she was frightened.
She had no connection to Richard Bennett, as far as she knew.
She had never heard of Blackwater House.
And she had no idea why her daughter's photograph appeared in a private medical facility.
Nathan and Olivia met Hannah at a neutral location arranged by investigators.
Lucy did not attend.
Hannah wanted to protect her from confusion until the adults understood what had happened.
Nathan respected that immediately.
Hannah sat across from them.
She looked exhausted.
“I don't understand any of this.”
Olivia reached for her hand.
“Neither do we.”
Hannah looked at the photograph.
“Lucy is my daughter.”
Nathan nodded.
“We're not here to take her away.”
Hannah's eyes filled with tears.
“I've raised her since she was three weeks old.”
Olivia squeezed her hand.
“We know.”
Hannah looked toward Nathan.
“Then what do you want?”
He took a breath.
“The truth.”
Hannah explained that Lucy's adoption had been arranged through a private agency.
The birth mother was listed as anonymous.
The father was unknown.
The paperwork appeared complete.
But the agency had closed two years later.
And the attorney who handled the placement had died.
Nathan asked for the attorney's name.
Hannah opened a folder.
“Graham Whitmore.”
Nathan felt the blood drain from his face.
Graham.
Again.
That evening, Detective Carter received another development.
The forensic team had recovered an encrypted file from Richard Bennett's former medical facility.
It contained several names.
Dates.
Payments.
And coded references to children.
One entry was labeled:
PROJECT MIRROR.
Beneath it were two names.
SOPHIE BENNETT.
LUCY PRICE.
The file also contained a third name.
EVELYN BENNETT.
Detective Carter frowned.
Evelyn Bennett.
She searched the family's records.
There was no child by that name.
No birth certificate.
No school enrollment.
No adoption record.
Nothing.
But beside the name was a photograph.
A newborn baby wrapped in a white blanket.
On the back, someone had written:
THE ORIGINAL.
Nathan received the call shortly before midnight.
He stood in the kitchen while Olivia slept upstairs beside Sophie.
Detective Carter's voice was tense.
“Mr. Bennett, we found another child connected to the records.”
Nathan gripped the phone.
“What child?”
“A baby identified as Evelyn Bennett.”
He frowned.
“I've never heard that name.”
“We haven't found a corresponding legal identity.”
Nathan felt cold.
“What does that mean?”
Carter hesitated.
“It means someone may have concealed the child's existence.”
Nathan stared toward the staircase.
“Whose child?”
The detective paused.
Then answered.
“We don't know yet.”
Nathan swallowed.
“Then why are you calling me?”
Carter took a breath.
“Because the file identifies Evelyn as the original subject of Project Mirror.”
Nathan felt his heart pound.
“And Sophie?”
Carter's voice became quieter.
“Sophie and Lucy were listed as secondary subjects.”
Nathan stared into the darkness.
“What was Project Mirror?”
The detective didn't answer immediately.
Then she said the words that would change the investigation forever.