Nora walked the far pier with her father's coat over her shoulders. David had wanted to come with her; she'd made him wait in the car at the lot's edge, engine running. *Come with your father — but not the police.* Iris's terms. Nora had bent the second one: before leaving the motel, she had texted June Park the marina's location and one line — *come quiet, come ready.*
The bait shop was a dark hump at the pier's end. Beneath its dripping awning stood a woman.
Nora stopped walking.
It was like facing a mirror in a dream — the kind where the reflection is a half-second slow. Same dark hair pulled back the same way. Same grey eyes. Same mouth. The woman wore a cheap windbreaker and jeans, and her hands were shoved deep in her pockets, and she was crying without making a sound.
"Hi," Iris said. Her voice was Nora's voice.
Nora's knees nearly gave. She reached the end of the pier and stood an arm's length from her own face, and the first absurd thought that surfaced was that the woman's left eyebrow was bisected by a thin white scar Nora didn't have.
"You cut your eyebrow," Nora said stupidly.
"Fell off a swing when I was nine." Iris laughed wetly. "The Holts — my parents, the people who raised me — they always said it gave me character. I used to wonder if you had one too. Somewhere."
"I don't." Nora touched her own unmarked brow. "Iris—"
"I know." Iris stepped forward, and then they were holding each other, two strangers with one face, shaking in the fog while gulls cried overhead and the halyards clinked against the masts like wind chimes. "I know," Iris whispered into Nora's shoulder. "Me too."
They sat on the damp boards with their backs against a piling, knees drawn up, mirror images. The fog had soaked through Nora's jeans. She didn't care.
"Tell me about them," Nora said. "The Holts. The people who raised you."
Iris's face did something complicated. "Good, ordinary people. He sold insurance in Seattle; she taught piano. They couldn't have kids, so they adopted, and they loved me like being wrapped in wool." She laughed shakily. "They died two years apart. Car accident, then cancer. I was nineteen and twenty-one. After that it was just me and the coffee shop and the rent."
"Did you know? About me? Before Marcus?"
"I knew I was adopted. The file was sealed, but I always—" Iris touched her own face, Nora's face. "I used to catch my reflection in windows and wonder if there was a reason I looked like someone's unfinished sentence. The Holts told me my birth mother was young and scared. I built a whole story where she was a hero." Her voice dropped. "Then Marcus showed me the truth. Nineteen, unmarried, terrified of her family. She kept you. She gave me away."
"She kept a secret for twenty-six years," Nora said. "Maybe she wasn't the villain in that story either. Maybe she was just nineteen."
Iris looked at her for a long moment. "You'd say that. You're the good one. You've always been the good one — that's what makes this so obscene."
For a while neither spoke. Then Iris began to talk, and the story came out in a rush, as if she'd been holding it behind her teeth for four years.
The documents first. "Three loan agreements, all in your name. A power of attorney giving Marcus control of a Halcyon account. I signed them at a bank downtown — the loan officer never looked at my face, just my signature. I'd practiced it for a month." Her mouth twisted. "I'm very good at being you, Nora. That's the worst part. I'm good at it."
Then the sightings. The gala — the Van Allen charity gala, silver dress, champagne. A restaurant on Harbor Street where "Nora Quinn" was seen having an intimate dinner with Marcus Webb, twice. A donation to the symphony in Nora Quinn's name.
"Why?" Nora asked. "Why be seen?"
"Alibis." Iris's voice went flat. "Every time Marcus needed to be somewhere he wasn't, or needed money to move while he was somewhere else — there I was. Nora Quinn, seen by witnesses, photographed by the society page. And every signature put another rope around your neck, in case you ever started asking questions." She picked at a hangnail. "He said it was insurance. I was insurance."
"The restaurant," Nora said. "Harbor Street. What was that like — sitting across from him, being me?"
Iris stared at the fog. "The first time, I ordered the wrong wine and he corrected me in front of the waiter. The second time I knew the menu by heart and hated the sound of my own laugh." She wrapped her arms around her knees. "There was a couple at the next table. The woman kept looking at us. Later I realized she probably thought — well. That Marcus Webb had a beautiful young girlfriend. That was the point, I think. Not just the alibi. He wanted people to see him with you. With *me-as-you.* It made him look untouchable."
Nora felt sick. "I'm sorry."
"Don't," Iris said sharply. Then, softer: "Don't. You're the one he did it to."
"And the plan," Nora said. "The original plan. What did he tell you?"
Iris was quiet for a long moment. Fog moved between them like something alive.
"We were in his car. He'd been drinking — which he almost never does. He said, 'You know what the elegant solution is, Iris? If your father ever crawls out of his grave, nobody will believe him. And if they do—' " She swallowed. " '—that's what the second Nora is for. A woman who insists she's Nora Quinn while the real one stands right there? They'll put her somewhere quiet and throw away the key. One Nora the world can see. One the world will never believe.' "
Nora felt the pier tilt under her. "He was going to have one of us committed."
"He was going to have *you* committed," Iris said softly. "I was always meant to be the spare."
---
Nora stared at the water slapping the pilings, and her own past three years began to come apart like wet paper.