I did not think. I grabbed my phone, opened the recording function, and stepped outside through the back door. My feet were bare on the patio stones, and the morning air was cold against my skin, and the spilled trash was at my feet, but I did not look down. I looked at Diane, who was still holding the second bag above the fence, and I said the first thing that came into my mouth.
"Looking for something?"
She froze. The bag stopped in midair. Her face, which had been set in concentration a second before, went completely still. For a moment neither of us moved, and the only sound was a bird somewhere beyond the fence and the distant hum of a car on the next street over. Then she lowered the bag slowly, back down to her side of the fence, and spoke.
"You were supposed to be at work."
It was not an answer. It was not an apology. It was not even a denial. It was a statement of fact, spoken as if the only thing wrong with the situation was that my schedule had not cooperated with her plan. I remember feeling a strange, detached anger at those words, because they told me everything: she had known when I was supposed to be gone, she had planned around my absence, and my presence was an inconvenience, not a surprise that changed anything.
"That isn't an answer," I said, and my voice was steadier than I felt.
"You need to go back inside," she said. Her voice was soft, the way it always was when other neighbors were watching, but there was something underneath it now, something urgent, something that did not sound like neighborly concern at all.
"You have been filling my house with trash for two months," I said. I said it plainly, because I wanted to hear it out loud, and because I wanted her to hear me say it.
"No," she said. It was quick and flat, a denial without any weight behind it.
"I just recorded you," I said, and I held up my phone so she could see it. "I just recorded you throwing that bag over my fence."
"I threw one bag into your yard," she said. She said it as if it were a correction, as if the distinction mattered, as if throwing one bag into a yard were a small, understandable thing and not the same as what had been happening inside my house for two months.
"That is not the same thing," I said, because I needed her to understand that I knew the difference, and that I was not going to let her blur it. "The bags inside my house did not come over the fence. They appeared in locked rooms. In my kitchen. In my bedroom closet. On the chair beside my bed."
"How does it get inside?" I asked her then, and I meant it as a real question, because I still did not know, and because I thought that if anyone would tell me, it might be the woman standing in front of me with a second bag of trash in her hands.
Her face changed. I have thought about that change many times since, trying to describe it accurately, and the closest I can come is this: it was not guilt. Guilt would have been easier to understand. Guilt would have meant she was sorry, or ashamed, or afraid of being caught. What I saw on her face was fear, pure and immediate, the fear of someone who has just realized that something much larger than herself is about to happen, and that she is standing in the middle of it. Her hands loosened on the second bag, and it dropped to the ground on her side of the fence with a soft, heavy sound.
"They know you found the addresses," she said. Her voice was barely above a whisper now, and she was not looking at me anymore. She was looking past me, toward the street, as if she expected someone to appear there at any moment.
"Who knows?" I asked. I stepped closer to the fence, still recording, and I could hear my own breathing, fast and shallow.
Before she could answer, a car door closed somewhere beyond her house. It was a sharp, distinct sound in the morning quiet, and Diane turned her head toward it instantly, the way a person turns toward a sound they have been dreading. Her face went paler, and she turned back to me, and her voice, when she spoke again, was urgent in a way I had never heard from her before.
"You need to leave before the county arrives," she said.