Naomi had spent the morning cooking in her own kitchen, with Amara asleep in the bassinet by the window and Marcus chopping vegetables at the counter beside her, and she had chosen the menu the way she chose everything now: simply, honestly, with the people she loved in mind. There would be roast chicken and rice and greens from Denise's garden, and a peach cobbler that Denise had insisted on bringing herself, still warm from her own oven. There would be no chandelier. There would be no silk the colour of champagne. There would be no one standing at a sink while everyone else sat in comfort.
The table was set for eight. Naomi counted the places twice, the way she always did, not because she doubted the number but because she wanted to be sure there was room for everyone.
Denise arrived first, carrying the cobbler and a jar of pickled okra, her garden dirt still faint under her fingernails despite the washing. She kissed Naomi's cheek and went straight to the bassinet to check on Amara, the way she always did, as if the baby might have changed in the hour since she had last seen her.
She's getting bigger, Denise said, lifting Amara gently. "Look at those cheeks."
She gets them from her father, Naomi said. "Marcus had cheeks like that in his baby pictures."
I never said that, Marcus said from the kitchen, but he was smiling.
Darius came next, with a wooden toy in a paper bag, a small train this time, painted red and blue, the wheels sanded smooth. He set it on the sideboard and stood awkwardly for a moment, as if he were still learning how to be welcome in a room, and then Denise pulled him into a hug and told him to sit down and stop hovering.
Priya arrived with a bottle of sparkling cider and a stack of drawings she had brought to show Naomi, not because they had to talk about work at dinner, but because Priya never could resist sharing a good detail when she found one. She kissed Amara's forehead and took the seat beside Naomi, and within minutes the two of them were leaning over the drawings, talking about foundation depths, until Marcus cleared his throat and said, "No work at the table. That is the rule. I made it up just now."
Bianca arrived alone, without the orange blouse and without the performance. She wore a simple dress and flat shoes, and she carried a bunch of flowers that looked as if she had picked them herself rather than ordered them. She stood in the doorway for a moment, looking at the table, at Denise holding Amara, at Darius sitting beside Priya, at Naomi in her own kitchen, and Naomi saw something in her sister-in-law's face she had never seen before: uncertainty, and underneath it, a willingness to try.
Thank you for inviting me, Bianca said quietly.
Thank you for coming, Naomi said, and she meant it.
Celeste came last, laughing before she was even through the door, her hair loose, her shoes in her hand, a bag of bread tucked under one arm. She had testified against Vivian, and the cost of that had been real, and Naomi knew it, and she also knew that Celeste had paid it without asking for anything in return. Celeste hugged Naomi hard, and then she hugged Denise, and then she went to the bassinet and made a face at Amara that made the baby kick her legs with delight.
She likes me best, Celeste announced.
She likes everyone best, Marcus said. "She is a politician."
They sat down to eat, and for a while there was only the sound of serving spoons and quiet conversation, the comfortable noise of people who were learning how to be together without a script. Denise told a story about Naomi as a little girl, trying to build a bridge out of blocks and crying when it fell, and then building it again, and again, until it stood. Darius told a story about the first toy he ever made, a crooked wooden duck that had one wing bigger than the other. Priya told a story about a building she had once worked on where the client had insisted on a glass staircase, and Naomi laughed until her eyes watered.
Bianca was quiet for most of the meal. She ate slowly, she listened, she watched Amara in Denise's arms, and Naomi could see her thinking, weighing something. When the plates were mostly empty and Marcus stood to clear them, Bianca put her hand on his arm.
Wait, she said. "I need to say something."
The table went quiet. Celeste put down her glass. Denise shifted Amara to her other shoulder. Darius folded his hands on the table.
Bianca looked at Naomi, and her eyes were bright, and her voice, when it came, was not the bright, sharp voice Naomi had heard in Vivian's living room. It was smaller, and it shook a little.
I was cruel to you, Bianca said. "At Mom's house, at dinners, for years. I made jokes about where you grew up and what your mother drove and whether you knew how to set a table. I did it because it was what Mom wanted, and because it made me feel like I belonged, and because I was afraid that if I didn't laugh, she'd turn on me next. That is not an excuse. I know it isn't. But it is the truth, and I wanted you to hear it from me."
Naomi did not speak. She felt Marcus's hand find hers under the table, and she held on to it, and she looked at Bianca, really looked at her, and she saw not the sister-in-law who had lounged on a sofa in an orange blouse, but a woman who was tired of performing for a mother who had never been satisfied, a woman who had finally stepped out from behind Vivian's shadow and was trying to find out who she was without it.