Brenda's attorney cross-examined Curtis for most of an afternoon, trying to make the jury believe that Curtis had built the operation himself and used his sister's HOA position as a cover, that she had never understood the dumping or the falsified tickets, that she had believed, in good faith, that homeowners were storing chemicals improperly and causing the contamination herself. Curtis answered each question in the same flat tone. He said Brenda had selected the access points. He said she had written the complaints. He said she had scheduled the inspections. He said she had kept the maps. When the attorney asked whether Brenda had ever driven a tanker truck, Curtis said no. When the attorney asked whether she had ever falsified a receiving ticket herself, Curtis said the tickets were his, but the addresses on them were hers. Noah watched the attorney try to separate the two of them, to draw a line between the woman who chose the houses and the man who moved the waste, and he watched the line refuse to hold, because the operation had needed both of them, and both of them had known it.
Noah testified on the fourth day. He had waited a year for that day, and when it arrived, he found that the waiting had not made it easier. He walked to the witness stand past rows of faces he did not know, past Mara, who sat in the second row with her hands folded in her lap, past the empty chair where Brenda's attorney would sit during the cross-examination. He raised his right hand and swore to tell the truth. Then he sat down, and the prosecutor asked him to begin at the beginning, and he told the court about the roses.
He described them the way he had described them to himself a hundred times since that Sunday morning. His mother had given him the original cuttings. He had planted them after her death. He had spent three springs restoring the bed beside the fence, working on it early on Sunday mornings, when the light was soft and the neighborhood was quiet. The first bloom appeared near the fence each spring. He told the jury that the roses were not valuable in the way a lawyer might mean valuable. They were not rare. They were not expensive. They were his mother's, and he had kept them alive, and that was the whole of it. He told the court about the gate, the locked gate, and the way it had opened behind him while he trimmed the roses. He told them about the weight of the bucket, the sludge running down his neck, the burning skin, the smell filling his nose and mouth. He told them about the moment he saw the photographs, the three images timestamped 7:42, and how he had looked at the patio clock and understood, before anyone else in the yard understood, that the pictures had been taken before the bucket had fallen.
The prosecutor asked him to describe the sludge. Noah said it was thick and black, heavier than water, and it clung to his skin and his clothes. He said it ran into his shoes and pooled around the rose bed. He said the odor was sharp and chemical, nothing like garden soil, nothing like anything he had ever handled in his shed. He said his skin started burning around his neck and forearms within seconds, and that he could not breathe properly for several seconds after the first rush of it covered his face. He said Mara had come out of the house, and Sophie had appeared in the doorway, and Mara had pushed their daughter back inside and told her to stay in the kitchen. He said he had stood in his own yard, covered in industrial waste, and listened to his neighbor tell a county inspector that he had poured it himself.
Then the defense attorney stood. Noah watched him walk to the lectern, arrange his notes, and look up at the witness stand with an expression Noah recognized from every HOA meeting he had ever attended. It was the expression of a man who believed the room belonged to him.
"You had argued with Mrs. Larkin before that morning, correct?" the attorney asked.
"Yes," Noah said.
"You disliked her?"
"I distrusted her."
"Because she enforced HOA rules."
"Because she invented violations."
The attorney paused, as if he had expected a different answer, and then moved on. "Did you ever store chemicals in your shed?"