My Neighbor Secretly Carried a Whole Sack of Broken Glass and Kept Dumping It Into My Pool — I Watched Her for an Entire Week Just to Find Proof of What She Was Doing

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I thought about that first morning, Monday, when Sophie had run out to the pool in her swimsuit, laughing, ready to jump in, and I had caught her arm at the last second because something on the water had caught my eye. I thought about her feet on the coping stone, about the way she would have gone in headfirst, about the glass under the surface, about the green shards and the clear shards and the brown bottle neck, and my hands shook harder, and I gripped the phone tighter, and I kept recording, because that was the only thing I could do, and because I knew that if I moved now, if I went out there too soon, she would stop, and she would leave, and I would have nothing but a video of a woman standing in my yard with a sack, and that would not be enough. Not for the police. Not for the HOA. Not for anyone.

She finished with the cover. She stood up straight and looked at the pool, and for a second she just stood there, looking at the water, and I could not read her face from where I was sitting. Then she folded the sack, the empty burlap sack, and tucked it under her arm, and she turned toward the gate, and that was when I stood up.

I opened the patio door. The sound of it was louder than I expected in the quiet morning, the slide of the door on its track, and Denise turned, and the sack dropped from under her arm onto the pavers, and for a second her face was all fear. Just fear, raw and open, her mouth open, her eyes wide, and then it was gone, and the composure came back, smooth and practiced, like a mask sliding into place, and she looked at me the way she had looked at me at the HOA meeting, the way she had looked at me every time I had seen her that week, calm and reasonable and a little bit sad, as if I were the one who had done something wrong.

"I caught you," I said. My voice sounded strange to me, too loud, too rough. "I caught you, Denise. On camera. All of it."

She looked at the phone in my hand. She looked at the pool. She looked at the sack on the ground. Then she bent down, slowly, and picked the sack up, and folded it over her arm, and said, "I found rubbish by the fence, Evan. I was returning something that belongs to your house."

"Rubbish," I said. "You poured it into my pool. I watched you pour it into my pool."

"The gate was open," she said. "The latch stuck. I came in to tell you about the rubbish, and the sack must have torn." She said it the way a person says something they have rehearsed, the words coming out even and steady, and she looked me straight in the eye while she said it, and I thought about how many times she must have practiced that in her head, how many mornings she must have stood in her kitchen and gone over what she would say if someone caught her.

"You were not returning anything," I said. "You brought it here. In a sack. At six twenty-one in the morning. In your pajamas."

"I did not dump glass in your pool," she said. "I would never do that. You have a little girl, Evan. Why would I do that to a little girl?"

"The police are on their way," I said. "I called them before I opened the door."

She went very still. "You called the police," she said, and it was not a question.

"I called them before I opened the door," I said again. "They are coming now."

She opened her mouth to say something else, and then a voice came from the side gate, calm and clear, and Talia Monroe stepped into the yard.

Talia was wearing a navy jacket and dark trousers, her black hair in a tight braid, a clipboard in one hand and a sealed sample box in the other. I had seen her twice that week, at the county office and on the phone, and I knew her as the woman from County Pool and Recreational Safety, the woman who had taken my report seriously when nobody else had, but I had not expected her to be here, not this morning, not now, and for a second I just stared at her.

"I heard the conversation from the gate," Talia said. She did not raise her voice. She did not need to. "I have been standing there since you opened the patio door, Mr. Rourke."

News in the same category

My Neighbor Secretly Carried a Whole Sack of Broken Glass and Kept Dumping It Into My Pool — I Watched Her for an Entire Week Just to Find Proof of What She Was Doing

45 Part