He had never fathered another daughter.
“This is impossible.”
Rebecca remained silent.
Arthur continued.
“It's another forgery.”
“Possibly.”
He shook his head.
“It has to be.”
But Rebecca had found something else.
A birth certificate.
Dated thirty-five years earlier.
It listed Arthur Whitmore as the father.
And a woman named Susan Bell as the mother.
Arthur stared at the name.
Susan Bell.
He remembered her.
A young woman who had worked at his company decades earlier.
She had been his assistant for six months.
Then she left.
Arthur had barely known her.
Rebecca asked carefully.
“Arthur, did you ever have a relationship with Susan?”
He shook his head.
“No.”
“Are you certain?”
He stared.
“Rebecca, I loved Margaret.”
She nodded.
“I understand.”
Arthur continued.
“I never had an affair.”
Rebecca looked down.
“Then someone may have created a false record.”
Arthur felt sick.
Charles was trying to manipulate his family again.
Another child.
Another secret.
Another document designed to create confusion.
That evening, Daniel arrived at Arthur's house.
He looked worried.
“Dad, Rebecca told me about Emily.”
Arthur nodded.
“It's a lie.”
Daniel hesitated.
“What if it isn't?”
Arthur stared.
“What?”
Daniel looked down.
“Mom never told us about the trust. Maybe there are other things we don't know.”
Arthur felt anger rise.
“Are you accusing me of having an affair?”
Daniel shook his head.
“No.”
“Then what are you saying?”
Daniel swallowed.
“I don't know.”
Arthur looked away.
For a moment, the fragile progress between them seemed to disappear.
Then Daniel spoke quietly.
“Dad, I don't want to fight.”
Arthur closed his eyes.
Neither did he.
Daniel continued.
“I just want to understand what's happening.”
Arthur looked toward him.
His son was frightened.
Confused.
Trying to rebuild trust while discovering that almost everything he believed about his family had been manipulated.
Arthur took a breath.
“Then we find the truth.”
Daniel nodded.
“Together?”
Arthur hesitated.
Then answered.
“Together.”
That night, Rebecca received a message from an unknown email address.
It contained a photograph.
A young woman stood beside a lake.
She had dark hair.
Blue eyes.
And a familiar smile.
Arthur recognized the resemblance immediately.
Margaret.
Beneath the photograph was a sentence.
EMILY WHITMORE IS REAL.
Then another.
BUT ARTHUR IS NOT HER FATHER.
Rebecca stared at the screen.
A final message appeared.
ASK MARGARET WHAT HAPPENED THIRTY-FIVE YEARS AGO.
Rebecca looked toward Margaret's photograph on her desk.
The dead woman had left behind more secrets than anyone imagined.
And one of them involved a daughter Arthur never knew existed.
Arthur stared at the photograph of Emily Whitmore.
The young woman looked about thirty-five.
She had dark hair.
Blue eyes.
And a smile that reminded him painfully of Margaret.
He had spent forty-six years married to his wife.
He believed he knew every important chapter of her life.
Now a photograph suggested she had a daughter he had never met.
Arthur felt as though the ground beneath him had disappeared.
Rebecca sat across from him.
“We need to verify the information.”
Arthur nodded.
“Of course.”
She hesitated.
“Do you recognize her?”
He shook his head.
“No.”
“Have you ever seen this photograph?”
“No.”
Arthur stared at the image.
“But she looks like Margaret.”
Rebecca nodded.
“She does.”
Daniel stood near the window.
He looked pale.
“If she's Mom's daughter…”
Arthur closed his eyes.
He couldn't finish the thought.
Had Margaret been pregnant before they married?
Had she given up a child?
Had someone forced her to?
Or was the entire story another manipulation created by Charles?
Rebecca contacted investigators.
The birth certificate was examined.
The document appeared to have been altered.
Arthur's name had been added later.
The original father field was blank.
But the mother's name was genuine.
Margaret Bell.
Her maiden name.
Arthur felt cold.
Margaret Bell.
The woman he married.
The woman he loved.
The woman who had never told him about a daughter.
The investigation located Susan Bell.
She was not Emily's mother.
She was Margaret's younger cousin.
Susan had helped arrange a private adoption thirty-five years earlier.
She was now sixty-seven and living in Vermont.
When Rebecca contacted her, Susan became frightened.
“Who told you about Emily?”
Rebecca explained.
Susan was silent for a long time.
Then whispered, “Margaret promised she'd never tell Arthur.”
Arthur traveled to Vermont with Daniel and Rebecca.
They met Susan in a small house surrounded by apple trees.
She was thin, with gray hair and tired eyes.
When she saw Arthur, she began crying.
“I'm sorry.”
Arthur stood in the doorway.
“For what?”
Susan looked down.
“For keeping Margaret's secret.”
They sat in the living room.
Susan explained that Margaret had become pregnant at seventeen.
Her family was deeply religious.
Her parents were strict.
And the father of the child refused responsibility.
Margaret was sent away to stay with relatives.
She gave birth to a daughter.
Then her parents arranged a private adoption.
Margaret was told she would never see the baby again.