Robert's office was on a quiet floor of a quiet building in New York, and it looked the way a careful man's office looks: nothing on the desk that did not need to be there, the blinds half drawn, a clock on the wall that ticked louder than it should have. He stood when Margaret and I came in. He was older than I remembered, which was to say that he looked like a man who had been carrying something heavy for a long time and had learned not to show it in his face.
"Eleanor," he said. "I have been waiting for this day for twenty years. I am sorry that it has come."
I sat down. My hands were steady. That surprised me. I had expected them to shake.
"My father came to you," I said. "In 1986."
"Yes," Robert said. "He came to me in the autumn of 1986. He did not call first. He arrived at my office in the morning, before my secretary, and he was sitting in the chair you are sitting in now when I walked in. He said, 'Robert, I need you to listen to me, and I need you to remember everything I say, because I may not be here to say it twice.'"
Robert folded his hands on the desk. His fingers were thin and pale, and there was a small ink stain on the side of his right thumb, the kind of stain a man gets from signing his name a thousand times.
"Your father had discovered something about Richard," he said. "He had discovered it before the wedding. Richard had been stealing. Not from the company, not yet. From smaller places. From people who trusted him. From a supplier who never checked his invoices. From a charity account that nobody watched. And when your father confronted him, Richard did not deny it. He threatened my family instead."
I felt my breath catch, the way it had caught on the river when the water closed over my head. I had been married to Richard for forty-six years. I had slept beside him. I had trusted him with my company and with my son. And here was a man I had not seen in twenty years, telling me that my father had known the truth before the wedding, and that the truth had been answered with a threat.
"What did he threaten?" I asked.
"He told your father that if he interfered, something would happen to my wife and my children," Robert said. "He said it plainly. He did not raise his voice. He said it the way a man says that the weather will change tomorrow. Your father believed him. He believed him because Richard had already shown him what he was willing to do."
Robert opened a drawer in his desk and took out a small device. It was a recording device, old-fashioned, the kind that used a small cassette, and it was wrapped in a piece of cloth that had once been white. He set it on the desk between us, gently, the way you set down something that is both fragile and dangerous.
"Two days before he died," Robert said, "your father gave me this. He said, 'Robert, if Richard does something I cannot stop, give this to Eleanor. Give it to her and tell her to listen to it all the way to the end.'"
I looked at the device. It was smaller than my hand. It had held my father's voice for twenty years, waiting for me.
"Why didn't you bring it to me sooner?" I asked. My voice was calm. I was proud of that. I had not meant to ask it as an accusation, and I hoped it did not sound like one.
"Because your father told me not to," Robert said. "He said, 'If you give it to her now, while Richard is watching, it will only make things worse. Wait until she comes to you. She will come to you when she needs it.' I have kept it in my desk for twenty years, Eleanor. I have kept it safe. I have never played it. I have never let anyone else hear it. It is yours now."
I looked at Robert Hale, and I saw him properly for the first time since I had walked into the room. He was not a young man anymore. None of us were. But there was something in his face that I recognised, because I had seen it in my own mirror in the hospital in Manaus: the look of a person who has carried a secret so long that it has become a part of the way he stands, the way he breathes, the way he keeps his hands folded so that no one can see them shake.
"Your family," I said. "Did Richard ever do anything to them?"