It was during that second visit that Mateo told her about the letters. He had not opened them. He had only noticed them, because the foundation's small office in Manaus received mail for Eleanor, and the envelopes from the prison had begun to arrive with a regularity that was hard to miss. Julian's handwriting was on the first of them, tight and careful, as if he had written it slowly, and Richard's was on the second, looser, more hurried, the letters slanting as if the writer had not been able to sit still. Mateo had set them aside in a drawer, unopened, and told Eleanor only when she asked him, directly, whether anything had come for her. She had thanked him for not opening them, and for not telling her sooner, and she had taken the small stack back to Virginia in her carry-on bag, where it sat on her desk for three weeks before she touched it.
The first letter from Julian was angry. She read it standing at the kitchen counter one evening, the light from the window fading, and she felt her hands go cold as she read words she had not heard from her son in years, words that blamed her for his sentence, for the loss of his name, for the collapse of the life he had built on her money. He wrote that she had ruined him, that she had chosen the company over her family, that she had never understood what it was like to live in the shadow of a woman who owned everything. She read it twice, then set it down, and went for a walk around the block, because she did not want to answer anger with anger, and she did not want to decide, in the heat of that moment, whether she would ever speak to him again. When she returned, she put the letter back in its envelope and placed it in the drawer, not because she was afraid of it, but because she understood that a letter written in anger was not a conversation. It was a wound looking for somewhere to bleed.
The second letter came a month later, and it was different. The handwriting was the same, but the tone had softened, as if the writer had been forced, by the long empty days in prison, to sit with himself in a way he had never done in his life. He apologized, not in the polished language of a man trying to negotiate his way out, but in short, plain sentences that sounded, for the first time in years, like the boy who had once brought her a drawing of a spaceship. He wrote that he was sorry for the river, for the boat, for standing at the railing and doing nothing while she struggled, for the forged signature and the succession papers, for every lie he had told Margaret Ellis and himself. He wrote that he had thought money would make him worthy of her, that he had spent his whole life believing that if he owned enough, controlled enough, impressed enough people, she would finally look at him the way she had looked at the company she built, with pride and without disappointment. He asked, at the end, if she would come to see him, just once, so that he could say it to her face, and so that she could see that he was not asking for her money, or her forgiveness, or her help getting out. He was asking only to be seen, by his mother, as a man who had done something terrible and knew it.
Eleanor did not answer for months. She read the letter again in the winter, and again in the spring, and each time she felt the same complicated pull: the part of her that was a mother wanted to go, wanted to sit across a table from her son and hold his hand, wanted to believe that the boy she had raised was still somewhere inside the man who had watched her drown. The part of her that was a survivor wanted to stay away, wanted to protect the peace she had built, wanted to refuse to let him use her love as a door back into a life he had forfeited. She talked about it with Margaret Ellis, who told her, as a lawyer and as a friend of twenty years, that there was no right answer, only the answer she could live with. She talked about it with Mateo, on a long phone call one evening, and he listened without advising her, which was his way, and then he said only that the river did not ask her to forgive the current. It asked her only to decide where she would stand. She talked about it with Claire, Julian's ex-wife, who had divorced him in the months after the trial and had since become a director of the foundation, and Claire told her, quietly, that Julian had been a man who wanted to be loved for what he owned, and that he had never learned to be loved for who he was, and that Eleanor could not teach him that from a distance, but she could not teach it to him by giving him what he wanted either.