I went to Robert Hale the morning after I found the note about the original agreement, and I went alone. Sarah wanted to come with me. Margaret Shaw wanted to send a car and a man to stand outside the door. I told them both no. Robert Hale had been my father's friend before I was old enough to know what a friend was, and if he was going to tell me the truth at last, he was going to tell it to me, not to a room full of lawyers. I drove myself. My hands did not shake on the wheel. That surprised me. I had expected them to shake. The river had taught me something about shaking, about how the body keeps moving after the mind has given up, and now my body seemed to have decided that it was done shaking for a while.
Robert's office was in a brick building that had once been a printing works, the kind of place where the stairs still smelled faintly of ink and the lift was too slow to be trusted. He had kept the same rooms for thirty years. His secretary was gone. The door was unlocked. He was standing at the window when I came in, his back to me, and he did not turn around for a long time. He was an old man now. I had forgotten how old he was. When my father was alive, Robert had been the younger of the two, the one who laughed louder and stayed later, and now he stood at that window with his shoulders bent under a weight I could almost see.
"Eleanor," he said, without turning. "I knew you would come. I have been waiting twenty years for you to come, and now that you are here, I do not know how to begin."
"Begin with my father," I said. "Begin with the truth, Robert. I have heard enough lies to last me the rest of my life."
He turned then, and his face was the face of a man who had carried a secret so long that it had worn grooves into him. He sat down behind his desk and folded his hands, and for a moment he looked like a man preparing to confess in a church. Then he began, and what he told me rearranged everything I thought I knew about my marriage, my father, and the forty-six years I had spent beside Richard Whitmore.
My father had discovered Richard stealing money before the wedding. Before the wedding. I had to make him say it twice, because the first time the words slid past me like something I had misheard. My father had found it in the accounts, small amounts at first, the kind of amounts a careful man could explain away, and then larger ones, and then a pattern that could not be explained at all. He had come to Robert in 1986, in this very office, and he had sat in the chair I was sitting in now, and he had said that he needed evidence to protect me. Not to punish Richard. Not yet. To protect me. He was going to marry his only daughter to this man, and he wanted to know exactly what kind of man he was marrying her to, and he wanted proof that would hold if the day ever came when I needed to be free of him.
"He loved you more than he trusted anyone," Robert said. "He said to me, 'Robert, if I am wrong about him, the evidence will prove it, and no harm will be done. If I am right, my daughter will need it.' He was a careful man, your father. He did not accuse without proof. He gathered it. Quietly. For years."
But my father died in 2006, and when he died, the evidence did not reach me. It never reached me. I asked Robert why, and he closed his eyes, and when he opened them again, they were wet.
"Because Richard produced a letter," he said. "After your father died, Richard came to me with a letter, supposedly from your father, saying that your father had changed his mind about leaving the assets. That he had reconsidered. That he wanted the arrangements altered. I knew your father's hand. I knew his words. The letter was wrong in a dozen small ways, and I told Richard so, to his face. And Richard did not argue with me. He simply told me what would happen to my family if I ever spoke about what your father had found, or about the letter, or about anything at all. He named my wife. He named my daughter. He named the street where my grandson went to school. He did not raise his voice. He did not need to."