Denise was in the kitchen when I got home, wiping the counter in slow circles, as if the counter were the only thing she could still control. She looked up when I came in, and she knew at once, the way a person always knows when the thing they have been afraid of has finally happened. I did not raise my voice. I had promised myself on the drive home that I would not raise my voice, because shouting would only make the children hide, and because I had already shouted once, in the kitchen, on the morning I had found the empty lunchbox, and shouting had not fed anyone. I told her, plainly, that I had filed a report with child welfare, that a caseworker would come to the house, that she would talk to the children, and that I had done it because Malik was my son and he had gone hungry in our house, and no father can live with that and call himself a father. Denise put the cloth down very carefully, as if she were afraid that if she let go of it she would fall apart, and then she began to cry, not loudly, but in the quiet, broken way that made me remember the woman I had married, the woman who had laughed in our kitchen when Kayla was small, and who had once held Malik's hand at a school fair without flinching. She said she was a good mother. She said Malik was exaggerating. She said I was trying to take her children from her. She said it again and again, as if saying it enough times would make it true, and I stood there and listened, and I did not argue, because arguing would not help, and because I knew that the caseworker would decide what was true, not the two of us, shouting in our own kitchen.
The caseworker came two days later. Her name was Sarah Kim, and she was younger than I had expected, and calmer than I had expected, and she carried a notebook and a small bag, and she shook my hand at the door as if she were visiting a neighbour, not investigating a family. She asked if she could see the house, and I said yes, and I showed her the kitchen, and the pantry, and the lock that was no longer on the pantry door, because I had taken it off the night before, with a screwdriver, while Denise watched me from the doorway and said nothing. Sarah Kim looked at the pantry, and she looked at the empty shelves, and she wrote something in her notebook, and she did not look shocked, and she did not look angry, and that, strangely, made me trust her more, because a person who has seen this before does not need to perform surprise. She asked to speak to the children separately, one at a time, in the living room, with the door open, and she asked Denise and me to wait in the kitchen, and to let her do her job, and I agreed, because I had asked for her to come, and because I had to let her do what I had asked her to do, even when it meant sitting in my own kitchen and listening to the low murmur of her voice through the wall, and not knowing what my children were saying.
She spoke to Malik first. He was gone for almost forty minutes, and when he came back to the kitchen his face was pale, and his hands were in his pockets, and he would not look at either of us, and I wanted to ask him what he had said, and I did not, because Sarah Kim had told me not to ask the children to repeat themselves, and because I knew that if I asked him he would have to live through it again, and he had already lived through it enough. She spoke to Kayla next, and then to Jordan, and each of them came back quieter than they had gone in, and each of them went to their rooms, and the house, which had always been noisy with music and television and arguing over the bathroom, went very quiet, the way a house goes quiet when everyone in it is waiting for someone else to decide what happens next. Denise sat at the kitchen table with her hands around a mug of tea she had not drunk, and I sat across from her, and neither of us spoke, because there was nothing left to say that had not already been said, in the kitchen, in Daniel's office, in the doctor's office, in the teacher's letter, and saying it again would not change any of it.
When Sarah Kim had finished with the children, she asked to speak to Denise alone, and then to me alone, and I waited in the hallway while she talked to my wife, and I could hear Denise crying, softly, behind the closed door, and I could hear Sarah Kim's voice, low and steady, asking questions, and I thought about all the times I had sat in hallways waiting for news about my children, in hospitals, in schools, in offices, and how waiting is the hardest part of being a parent, because you cannot do anything except wait, and hope that the person behind the door is being honest, and that the person asking the questions is being fair. When it was my turn, Sarah Kim asked me about Malik's weight, about the lunchbox, about the pantry, about what I had seen and when I had seen it, and about what I had done when I had seen it, and I told her everything, plainly, without making excuses for myself, because I had already made enough excuses, to myself, for months, and I was tired of them. I told her I had not seen it soon enough. I told her I had believed Denise when she said it was about money. I told her I had been at work, and tired, and that I had trusted my wife to feed my children, because that is what a husband is supposed to do, and that trusting her had been a mistake, and that I would not make it again.