I looked toward the sky. The afternoon was hot and still, but the western clouds had begun stacking above the hills. Every local forecast warned of a severe overnight thunderstorm. Heavy rain. Strong wind. Possible flash flooding. Heather had chosen the afternoon before that storm to cut the main drainage line off my roof.
I pointed at the broken pipe. “You knew exactly when to do this.” She picked up the saw. “You should have installed it correctly the first time.” “It was inspected when the house addition was built.” “That permit is outdated.” “Drainage laws don’t expire because you don’t like them.” “Keep telling yourself that.” She carried the severed extension toward the fence. “Put that down.” “It’s affecting my property.” “It’s mine.” “I removed it from a problem area.” “You removed it from my yard.”
She dropped the pipe on my grass. Then she stepped through the gap in the hedge and returned to her own property. Before leaving, she turned.
“The inspector is coming at nine.” “Tomorrow?” “Yes.” “Convenient.” “Clean up your mess before then.” She smiled. Then she went inside.
My name is Daniel Mercer. My wife, Rachel, and I bought the house on Cedar Way eleven years earlier. We had two children: Luke, thirteen, and Emma, ten. The house was nothing fancy. Three bedrooms. A finished basement. A small deck. A narrow side yard between us and the Barlows.
The drainage system had never been interesting until Heather decided it was.
The trouble had begun six months earlier. Heather and her husband, Paul, had lived next door almost as long as we had. Paul traveled often for work and avoided HOA politics. Heather did not. Three years earlier, she joined the Cedar Way Architectural Committee. The following year, she became HOA vice president. By the time the drainage complaints started, she controlled nearly every property-enforcement discussion.
The first notice said my downspout “directed runoff toward neighboring land.” I walked outside during the next rain. It did not. The downspout fed a buried pipe that ran forward twenty-seven feet and discharged through a grated outlet beside my driveway. I photographed it. Heather replied that underground water might still be “migrating laterally.”