Michael stepped closer. “What kind of jar?”
“Like Mommy’s spice jars,” Sophie said. “Then Uncle Joseph came in and asked if she did what she wanted. And Aunt Lisa said… the cake would be the death of us.”
The words fell like stones.
Joseph shifted beside Lisa, saying nothing.
Lisa’s composure cracked. “Oh, come on. That’s not what I meant! I wasn’t trying to poison anyone.”
“Then what did you put on it?” Michael asked.
She hesitated.
“Pepper. Salt. Maybe some sand,” she admitted finally. “Just enough to ruin the taste.”
“Why?” I asked, my throat tight.
Her frustration spilled out.
“Because it’s always you, Elaine! Your house, your dinners, your perfect baked goods. And then the inheritance—your parents give you the house and the jewelry. Joseph gets the farm and an old Subaru. We’re supposed to smile while you play the golden daughter. I just wanted to knock you down a little.”
The room felt suffocating.
“I didn’t mean real harm,” she added bitterly. “It was petty. Not lethal.”