Nicole pulled into the gas station. A quiet pump, a quiet lot, a pickup truck parked in the corner, an old man inside the convenience store staring at a lottery ticket, and across the road, a police cruiser. Three officers inside watching. Nicole pulled up to pump number two and killed the engine. The gas station was the kind of place that looked like it hadnât been painted since the â90s. cracked concrete, a faded sign that read Greyfield Gas and Go in letters that used to be red.
Audrey stepped out and stretched. The heat hit her like a wall. How does anyone live out here? People live everywhere, Audrey. Not by choice.
Nicole swiped her card at the pump. Audrey walked toward the convenience store. The door chime was broken. Made a sound like a dying bird. Inside, an old man stood at the counter scratching a lottery ticket with a quarter.
He looked up when Audrey walked in, looked her up and down, then went back to scratching. The woman behind the register didnât say hello. Audrey grabbed two bottles of water and a bag of grapes. She put them on the counter. The woman rang them up without a word.
No eye contact, no have a nice day, just the total on the screen. Audrey paid, walked out. She was used to it. Small towns in Georgia had a way of saying everything without opening their mouths. The silence was louder than any slur.
Back at the pump, Nicole was leaning against the car phone to her ear. Yes, mama. Weâre close. Maybe 40 minutes. No, I didnât bring flowers.
Yes, I brought fruit. Audrey picked grapes. I know you wanted strawberries. Take it up with her. Audrey could hear Eleanorâs voice through the speaker.
Thin, but still bossy. still. Eleanor, tell her I said the grapes were the only ones that looked fresh. Audrey called out. Nicole tilted the phone. She says, âI heard her.
Tell her sheâs cheap. And tell her I love her. â Audrey smiled. It felt like every visit might be the last one. Eleanor never complained, never talked about the cancer like it was winning, but her voice was thinner every time they called, and the silences between her sentences were getting longer. The pump clicked off.
Nicole hung up, put the nozzle back, screwed the gas cap on. Ready? Yeah, letâs Audrey stopped. She had that look, the one Nicole had seen a hundred times. Eyes narrow, head slightly tilted like a dog that just heard something no one else could hear.
What? Nicole asked. Cruiser across the road. Three guys inside. Theyâve been watching us since we pulled in.
Nicole looked. A police cruiser sat in the shade of an oak tree on the other side of the two-lane road. She could see the shapes of three officers behind the windshield. So, weâre just getting gas. I know.
Audrey, donât. Iâm not doing anything. Audrey took a sip of water. Casual, but her left hand drifted to the pendant under her shirt. A habit like checking for your keys before you leave the house.
Nicole shook her head. You see cops everywhere. I investigate cops everywhere. Thereâs a difference. Nicole got behind the wheel.
Audrey opened the passenger door. Thatâs when the cruiser pulled out of the shade. Slow. No sirens, no lights, just a slow roll across the two-lane road straight into the gas station lot. It parked behind the Lexus, blocking them in.
Three doors opened. Three officers stepped out. Sergeant Wade Thornton, Officer Brett Lawson, Officer Kyle Greer. Thornton looked at the Lexus, then at Audrey, then at Nicole in her red dress behind the wheel. He said something to Lawson low enough that only the three of them could hear.
Lawson laughed. Then Thornton put on his sunglasses, even though he was already standing in shade, and walked toward them. Man, imagine just stopping for gas and thatâs enough to ruin your whole day. Just two sisters buying water. Thatâs it.
But nah. Wrong skin color, nice car. Now youâre a suspect. Tell me that doesnât make your blood boil. Thornton reached the Lexus first.
He didnât say hello. Didnât say good afternoon. He slapped the hood twice with his palm like calling a dog. Out of the car, both of you. Nicole turned off the engine and stepped out slowly.
Audrey was already standing by the passenger side water bottle still in her hand. Thornton looked at the Lexus, then at Audrey, then at Nicole. He took his time, eyes moving from Nicoleâs red dress to her sandals to her face. Registration and license now. Nicole reached into the car and pulled out the documents, held them out.
Thornton took them, looked at the name, looked at Nicole, looked at the name again. âNicole Shaw? â He said it like he was tasting something bad. This your car? Yes, sir. Paid for it yourself?
Yes. Thornton turned to Lawson. You believe that? Lawson shook his head, grinning. Greer leaned against the cruiser with his arms crossed, chewing gum.
Thornton held the registration up to the sunlight, squinting. This looks off to me. Itâs not off. Itâs from the Lexus dealership in Did I ask you where itâs from? Thornton stepped closer.
Close enough that Nicole could smell the cigarette on his breath. I said it looks off. That means it looks off. You understand that, sweetheart? Or do I need to speak slower?
Nicoleâs jaw tightened. I understand. Good girl. Audrey set her water bottle down on the roof of the car. Slow. calm.
Her voice came out flat. Sergeant, youâve seen the registration. Youâve seen her license. Is there something else you need? Thornton turned to Audrey like heâd just noticed her.
He looked her up and down, fitted black tee jeans, sneakers. Then he smiled. The kind of smile that isnât a smile. What about you? You got ID in my bag.
In the car. Go get it. Audrey reached into the car and pulled out her wallet, handed him her driverâs license. Thornton held it between two fingers. Audrey Shaw.
Same last name, same face. He looked back and forth between them. Twins. Yes. Huh?
Thornton flicked the license with his thumb. Two black girls, same face, same car. You know what that usually means around here? Audrey didnât answer. She knew exactly what he wanted her to say.
Thornton didnât wait. It usually means one of you stole it and the other oneâs along for the ride. He tossed both IDs onto the ground. The license skidded under the car. The registration landed in a small puddle of oil.