Then removal, which mattered to me more than any dollar figure on the page. Fifteen thousand dollars, paid by the association, for excavation and supervised removal of the line from my land. The work to be done under county supervision, on a schedule the county approved. The line to be cut and capped at the boundary, on the Bellweather side, at association expense, so that nothing of theirs remained in my ground and nothing of mine was left connected to anything of theirs. Rachel read those terms twice, slowly, because I had told her I would sign nothing that left the blue pipe sleeping in my field as a settled inconvenience. I wanted it out, coil by coil, and I wanted a county man standing there while it came out.
Legal fees came last: $37,000, mine, documented to the hour. Whitaker winced, which I thought was honest of him. Ellis added the column himself on his yellow pad, the way I would have, carrying the numbers twice to be sure. Water $4,850, electricity $3,150, pump wear and well service $6,400, trespass $30,000, removal $15,000, legal fees $37,000. Total, $96,400. He read it aloud. Nobody in the room disputed the addition.
We broke twice. The association caucused and phoned its insurer. Peg stood near the water fountain during the second break, where a conversation could happen without being one. "It will settle today, Gavin," she said. "I will see that it does." I nodded. I did not thank her in advance.
By four o'clock the terms were written, read back, and signed in the places Ellis marked. A settlement, recorded, with the removal schedule attached and the supervision clause spelled out in language Rachel had drafted herself. No apology clause. I had not asked for one. An apology you have to order in writing is just another kind of paper, and I had enough paper. What I had, instead, was a number that added up and a date by which the blue line would be out of my ground. Ellis shook my hand on the way out and said, "You kept good records, Mr. Alden." I said that was the whole of it. It was not quite the whole of it, but it was the part that fit in a hallway.
Greg Halloran pleaded guilty on a Tuesday morning in the county courthouse, in a courtroom that smelled of old varnish and floor cleaner, three floors below the room where we had settled. I went because Rachel thought I should, and because I wanted the record of my own eyes on it, not a summary afterward. I sat in the second row behind the prosecutor's table. Halloran stood with his attorney in a suit that looked borrowed for the day, a size too careful, and when the judge asked him how he pleaded to misdemeanor utility theft, he said, "Guilty, Your Honor," in a voice that barely reached the first row.
The judge read the facts as they had been agreed. That Halloran, as community manager of Bellweather Pines, had arranged for a contractor to connect an association irrigation line to a private well system on adjoining land, without the knowledge or consent of the owner. That the connection had operated across two irrigation seasons. That the volume taken was 413,800 gallons. Hearing the number in that room, read from a court document by a man in a robe, gave it a different weight than it had in my notebook. In the notebook it had been arithmetic. In court it was a finding. Halloran did not look up while it was read. He looked at a point on the table in front of him, the way men look at a place where their hands might have been if they had not been folded.
The sentence was what Rachel had predicted: a fine, probation, and restitution folded into the civil settlement, so that the $96,400 stood as the money of the matter and the criminal case added its own mark. No jail. I had never wanted jail for him; Rachel said wanting proportion was not softness. Halloran was not a mastermind. He was a manager with a permit cap, a drought, and a landscaping standard he could not meet lawfully. He had solved it by stealing from the man next door, quietly, at night, and calling it temporary. Temporary had lasted two summers because nobody with authority to stop it had wanted to know how it worked.
The association had fired him the week before the plea. The termination letter, which Peg sent me a copy of because the settlement required the association to confirm it in writing, was three sentences long and used the word separated, as if Halloran and his employment had drifted apart by weather. Peg told me later the board had argued for an hour over that word. She had wanted terminated for cause, in plain English, in the record. She lost that vote, one of the last votes the old board took in its old shape. It did not matter much. A man who pleads guilty to stealing water does not get his job back on the strength of a euphemism.
Verdant Works took its reckoning in a different building, through paper rather than a courtroom, which suited it. The state water authority issued its findings in October: a penalty against the company for installing an unpermitted withdrawal connection, assessed and paid without a hearing, because Sal Romano, when his turn came to decide how much of this he wanted read aloud in public, chose to pay. Romano's contractor license was placed on probation, with conditions: no irrigation work involving a private well connection without documented permits filed in advance, and a state review of his jobs for the period of the probation. Rachel explained the practical meaning to me over the phone. He could work. He would work watched. Every permit he filed would be read by a person who knew his name now.