PART2 HOA Karen Called Deputies to Open My Gate — Then Used Their Report to Take Control Anyway

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I spent the first evening organizing the files.

The stormwater contract was straightforward enough. The original scope included excavation, installation of drainage pipe, replacement of a damaged culvert, and restoration of the disturbed ground.

A change order had been issued after the contractor discovered an unexpected underground obstruction.

The revised cost was higher than the original estimate.

That was not unusual. Construction projects often encountered conditions that could not be identified before excavation.

The concern was that the final payment appeared to have been authorized before the contractor's own completion certificate was signed.

I checked the dates.

The association's payment authorization was dated May 12.

The contractor's completion certificate was dated May 19.

A photograph attached to the certificate showed the work area, but the image was too limited to establish whether every section of the planned drainage system had been installed.

I made notes.

Then I opened the next folder.

It contained the board minutes.

The access provision appeared in a draft policy circulated to the board several months earlier.

The draft stated that the association could request reasonable access for inspections when necessary to investigate a specific violation.

That language was narrower than the version Carol had sent me.

The draft also included a paragraph requiring advance notice and written identification of the purpose of any inspection.

Those safeguards had disappeared from the revised version.

I searched the meeting minutes for a vote approving the final language.

There was no recorded vote.

There was, however, a reference to a discussion concerning "enhanced property oversight."

The minutes stated that Carol had been asked to prepare a revised policy for consideration at a later meeting.

I found no record of that later consideration.

The document Carol had sent me was marked "Revised Enforcement Policy — Final."

Its electronic metadata showed that the file had been created by Carol's account on a Tuesday evening.

The metadata alone proved nothing improper. Presidents often prepared administrative documents.

But the absence of a recorded approval meant that the policy's authority was questionable.

I printed the relevant pages and placed them beside the copy of Carol's demand letter.

The wording was nearly identical.

She had demanded unrestricted access using language that did not appear in the approved governing documents.

I continued through the archive.

Then I found the email.

It was part of a correspondence thread between Carol and the association's former management company.

The subject line read: Gate Access — Wittmann Property.

The message had been sent six weeks before Carol's first formal demand.

I opened it.

Carol had written that the new gate created an "unacceptable obstacle to association oversight."

She asked whether the management company could require homeowners to provide access codes as part of the annual compliance process.

The management company's representative replied that the association's authority was limited and that a blanket access requirement would likely need a valid basis in the governing documents and applicable law.

The representative advised Carol not to demand unrestricted access without consulting the association's attorney.

Carol responded that the issue would be addressed through a revised enforcement policy.

I read the exchange twice.

There it was.

Before she sent the first letter, Carol had already been warned that her proposed demand might exceed the association's authority.

She had not been confused.

She had not simply misunderstood the rules.

She had asked the question, received a caution, and proceeded anyway.

I sat back in my chair.

The room was quiet except for the hum of the computer.

For months, I had wondered whether Carol's behavior was the result of incompetence, personal resentment, or a genuine belief that the association could control anything it considered inconvenient.

The email suggested something more deliberate.

She had wanted access.

When the existing rules did not give her what she wanted, she attempted to create a policy that did.

I saved the email in three locations.

Then I found another document.

It was a spreadsheet containing enforcement statistics for the previous two years.

The file had apparently been prepared for an internal board discussion.

It listed the number of violations issued, the amount of fines assessed, the amount collected, and the number of appeals.

The figures showed a dramatic increase in enforcement activity after Carol became president.

That increase alone was not evidence of wrongdoing. A new president might discover neglected maintenance issues or decide to enforce rules that had previously been ignored.

But the spreadsheet contained another column.

It was labeled Resolution Type.

The entries included categories such as corrected, withdrawn, appealed, and referred to counsel.

Several of my notices had been classified as corrected even though I had never changed anything.

The hedge violation was listed as corrected.

The irrigation citation was listed as corrected.

The fence-height citation was listed as corrected.

The paint citation was listed as corrected.

I had not corrected those conditions because the conditions had not existed.

The notices had been withdrawn after I supplied evidence.

Yet the spreadsheet recorded them as successful enforcement actions.

I wondered whether the same classification had been used for other residents.

I began comparing the records.

Elaine Mercer's ramp violation had been marked corrected.

Denise Parker's fence citation had been marked corrected.

Another homeowner's mailbox dispute had been marked corrected.

In each case, the underlying correspondence showed that the association had withdrawn the notice or accepted the homeowner's explanation without requiring a change.

The internal statistics therefore gave a misleading impression of enforcement success.

I could not determine whether the misclassification was intentional.

But I could demonstrate that the numbers did not accurately describe what had happened.

I called Thomas.

"Have you ever seen the association's enforcement statistics?"

"No. Why?"

"I think you should."

I sent him a copy of the relevant pages, along with the documents concerning the stormwater contract.

He called back twenty minutes later.

"David, this is bad."

"It's incomplete."

"That's not what I mean."

He sounded angry.

"People have been paying fines because they think they've violated something. Meanwhile, the board is reporting these as corrected violations even when nothing needed correcting."

"Some people may have paid because they wanted the dispute to end."

"And Carol gets to say her enforcement program is working."

I understood his frustration.

The problem was not simply that Carol had issued inaccurate notices.

It was that the association's records might have transformed those notices into evidence of success.

A system could become self-reinforcing.

The more notices Carol issued, the more violations appeared in the statistics.

The more violations appeared in the statistics, the more she could argue that stricter enforcement was necessary.

And the more she argued for stricter enforcement, the more power she gained over the residents she was supposed to serve.

I printed the relevant documents and created an index.

I included the source of each record, the date it had been produced, and the specific question it raised.

I also included a warning to myself.

Do not claim more than the evidence establishes.

The stormwater records raised questions about timing and completion.

The policy records raised questions about authorization.

The enforcement spreadsheet contained apparent classification errors.

The email showed that Carol had been cautioned about the limits of her authority before demanding access to my gate.

News in the same category

PART2 HOA Karen Called Deputies to Open My Gate — Then Used Their Report to Take Control Anyway

20 Part