PART2 HOA KAREN DRAINED MY $8 MILLION RESERVOIR FOR HER LAWNS — THEN A JUDGE MADE HER PAY $12 MILLION

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The attorney tried again.

"The community faced severe landscape damage."

Judge Hale looked over his glasses.

"Grass is not an emergency."

The courtroom went silent.

That sentence would appear in newspapers across the state.

Karen testified on the fourth day.

Rachel handled the cross-examination.

She didn't shout.

She didn't need to.

"Ms. Whitmore, did Mr. Mercer give you permission to divert his water?"

"No."

"Did the state?"

"No."

"The county?"

"No."

"Any water district?"

"No."

"Did you know Cedar Creek Meadows was under watering restrictions?"

"Yes."

"Did you know those restrictions applied to lawns and ornamental landscaping?"

"Yes."

Rachel paused.

"Did you divert the water for drinking?"

"No."

"For fire suppression?"

"No."

"For sanitation?"

"No."

"For crops?"

"No."

Rachel looked directly at her.

"For lawns, gardens and fountains?"

Karen hesitated.

"Community landscape preservation."

Rachel nodded.

"For lawns, gardens and fountains."

Karen said nothing.

Rachel projected the email.

There is our solution.

"Is this your email?"

"Yes."

"And when you wrote, 'There is our solution,' what solution were you referring to?"

Karen shifted in her chair.

"The availability of regional water."

"Mr. Mercer's water?"

"I viewed it as part of the watershed."

"Did you own it?"

"No."

"Did the HOA own it?"

"No."

"Did you have a diversion right?"

"No."

Rachel looked toward the judge.

Then back at Karen.

"You were trying to protect the color green."

Karen's face flushed.

"You don't understand what it takes to maintain a neighborhood."

Rachel stepped back.

"No further questions."

She didn't need another question.

Karen had already said everything.

The Twelve-Million-Dollar Judgment

Judge Hale issued his ruling two weeks later.

He found that Cedar Creek Meadows HOA, acting through Karen Whitmore and authorized agents, had unlawfully diverted water from my protected reservoir system.

He found the diversion intentional.

He found the environmental damage foreseeable.

He found the infrastructure damage supported by overwhelming expert evidence.

And he rejected the HOA's claim that internal bylaws somehow gave it the power to take my water.

Then he announced the damages.

Direct repair and restoration:

$8 million.

Punitive damages:

$4 million.

Total:

$12 million.

The courtroom went silent.

But Judge Hale wasn't finished.

He also awarded attorney's fees, monitoring costs and extensive injunctive relief.

The injunction permanently prohibited Cedar Creek Meadows, its board, agents, contractors and anyone acting on its behalf from interfering with my reservoir, creek, water rights, control structures or ecological restoration zone.

Then he looked directly at Karen.

"Private property is not a reservoir of convenience for those who dislike the limits of their own planning."

He paused.

"Water rights are not created by desire."

Another pause.

"And a homeowners association is not a government with power to appropriate what it does not own."

Karen sat motionless.

Twelve million dollars had just turned her landscaping project into one of the most expensive HOA mistakes in the state's history.

The Price of Green

The HOA didn't have twelve million dollars.

The insurance company refused to cover intentional misconduct.

The reserve fund disappeared first.

Then the clubhouse was listed.

Then the community center.

News in the same category

PART2 HOA KAREN DRAINED MY $8 MILLION RESERVOIR FOR HER LAWNS — THEN A JUDGE MADE HER PAY $12 MILLION

7 Part