The city issued a cease-and-desist order concerning roadway enforcement.
New signs appeared around Oakridge.
PUBLIC CITY ROADWAY
CITY PARKING REGULATIONS APPLY
HOA ROADWAY ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITY DOES NOT APPLY
The first time I saw one, I took a photograph.
Daniel printed it.
Then he framed it.
"For your living room," he said.
"I am not hanging a parking sign in my living room."
"You're no fun."
The financial fallout was even worse.
The HOA didn't have enough money to reimburse everyone.
The road-maintenance reserve had to be audited.
Some spending was legitimate.
Some was questionable.
The towing rebates created another problem.
Metro Safe Tow initially claimed it had simply relied on HOA representations.
But investigators discovered inconsistencies in the company's records.
Some documents described Oakridge as private.
Others used city street addresses.
Several drivers had questioned whether the roads were public.
The company kept towing anyway.
Its operating license came under regulatory review.
Contracts were canceled.
Insurance problems followed.
The business eventually collapsed.
One afternoon, Travis called me.
"I wanted to say I'm sorry."
"You don't have to apologize to me."
"Yeah, I do."
He sounded tired.
"I knew something was weird."
"What?"
"The signs."
"What signs?"
"Normal private communities have signs at the entrances explaining towing rules."
Oakridge didn't.
I had never noticed.
"We asked Marcus about it once," Travis continued. "He said the HOA didn't want ugly signs lowering property values."
"And you kept towing."
"Yeah."
There was a pause.
"That's on us."
At least somebody eventually admitted it.
The Cost of Being Right
Marcus's case took much longer than I expected.
Real criminal proceedings weren't anything like television.
There were hearings.
Motions.
Financial reviews.
Arguments over intent.
Arguments over authority.
Arguments about what Marcus knew and when he knew it.
Investigators eventually found evidence that Marcus had been warned years earlier that the ownership of Oakridge Court needed to be verified.
A former board member produced an email from six years earlier.
It said:
We should confirm city right-of-way status before expanding towing enforcement.
Marcus had replied:
Our historical practice establishes authority. Proceed under current policy.
Historical practice.
We have been doing it, therefore we can do it.
That sentence became painful for his defense.
Another email from Metro Safe Tow asked for proof that Oakridge streets were private.
Marcus provided an HOA map.
Not a deed.
Not an easement.
Not a county record.
A map created by the HOA.
Metro Safe Tow accepted it.
The system continued.
Hundreds of people paid.
Nobody checked the original documents.
Until I did.
But I didn't feel like a hero.
Mostly, I felt exhausted.
Reporters called.
Neighbors stopped me at the grocery store.
People knocked on my door carrying old towing receipts.
Some thanked me.
Some blamed me.
One man told me:
"Things worked fine before you started digging."
I stared at him.
"Were you ever towed?"
"No."
"Then maybe they worked fine for you."
He walked away angry.
The board collapsed within weeks.
Cheryl resigned.
Several other members resigned.
Paul hired an attorney.
An interim management group took over the association while elections and audits were conducted.
For the first time, homeowners could see the association's financial records.
The road-maintenance category became the center of outrage.
Residents discovered that the money had funded a mixture of legitimate expenses, reserve allocations, unrelated maintenance, and administrative costs even though the city had responsibility for the actual roadway.
The accounting was messy enough that nobody could determine exactly where every dollar had gone.
Civil claims followed.
The question had changed.
It was no longer:
Why was Maya's car towed?
It became:
What exactly has this board been doing with our money?
Eventually, repayment became the priority.
Claims were reviewed.
Receipts were verified.
Tow records were obtained.
The total exceeded $180,000.
My own towing expenses were eventually reimbursed.
Every dollar.
I stared at the check for several minutes.
More than four thousand dollars.
Money that should never have left my account.
Money I had paid because I needed my car to get to work.
I thought about everything I had delayed.
Dental work.
A weekend trip with my sister.
Replacing my old mattress.
Then I bought the mattress.
My sister and I went to dinner.
She raised her glass.
"To the four inches."
I laughed.
"To checking the records."
Just Ask Questions
The annual HOA election after the scandal drew the largest turnout Oakridge had ever seen.
Nearly every household participated.
Nobody wanted another Marcus.
Candidates were asked difficult questions.
Who owns the roads?
Public.
Who controls municipal parking?
The city.
Can the HOA tow from city streets as though they are private property?
No.
Where are reserve funds held?
Separate accounts.
Will financial records be available?
Yes.
Does the president have unilateral enforcement authority?
No.
The new HOA president was Teresa Long, a retired school principal.
At her first meeting, she placed a small wooden sign beside the microphone.
ASK QUESTIONS.
Marcus would have hated it.
I loved it.