The energy shifting from uncomfortable to curious, from embarrassed to entertained. Yale's throat tightened. His hands went cold. But he crossed to the bench, set his cane against it, sat down. The keys under his fingers, warm from her hands, familiar from tuning, foreign for playing.
Not here, not in front of these people, not as entertainment for their judgment. He found middle C, placed his hands in position, started something simple, Mozart, sonata in C major, the opening phrase, clean, basic, something to satisfy her curiosity, and then stop. Ten seconds. She had given him ten seconds. Can you even find middle C without seeing it?
Without sheet music to guide you?
Someone laughed. Victoria continued, "Playing by ear is not playing. It is mimicry. It is parroting what you have heard without understanding what you are doing."
Without understanding theory, structure, history, context. Yale's fingers stayed on the keys. Frozen. You seem like a hardworking young man, Victoria said, choosing her words carefully. Coded language.
"And I am sure you do your best, but there is a reason we have conservatories," Victoria continued. "There is a reason we study for years—decades. It is not gatekeeping. It is standards." She walked back to the piano and stood beside him. "Some people are born with the resources, education, and cultural background to understand classical music. Others should focus on what they are already good at, like tuning. You are clearly skilled at that. Stick with it."
Sophie Mitchell, a student in the front row whose voice Yale had heard before, started to speak. "Maybe we should—" One look from Victoria silenced her. "Natural talent only goes so far," Victoria continued.