It was during the second half of the class, when the students were practising in pairs, that Sarah first saw Grace Liu. Grace was thirty-eight, a fellow parent, and a beginner, and Sarah knew this because Karen Doyle had introduced them in the few minutes before the class began, when Grace had come in with her daughter's water bottle in her hand and the slightly harried air of a woman who had come straight from somewhere else. Grace Liu had dark hair pulled back in a ponytail, and she wore a white gi that was new enough to still hold its creases, and a white belt that sat a little crooked, and she moved the way beginners move, with care and with uncertainty, and with a determination that was easy to see if you knew how to look. She was paired with a woman about her own age, and the two of them were working on a simple balance exercise, one holding the other's sleeve, the other trying to step and turn without pulling, and Grace kept laughing at herself, not in embarrassment but in the way people laugh when they are learning something that is harder than it looks and they have decided to enjoy the difficulty rather than fight it. She caught Sarah's eye at one point, across the mat, and she smiled, a small, open smile, and Sarah smiled back, and there was a moment of recognition between them, the recognition of two women who had come to the same room for different reasons and found themselves, for a little while, in the same place.
After the class, when the students were bowing and the mats were being swept, Grace Liu came over to the benches, and she sat down beside Sarah, and she asked about Noah, because she had heard about the shoulder, and she asked about it the way a parent asks, with the particular concern of someone who has a child in the same world and knows how quickly a small injury can become a big worry. Sarah told her what Dr. Helen Cho had said, and Grace listened, and she nodded, and she said that her own daughter had once sprained an ankle in a school game, and that the waiting had been the hardest part. Then she talked about herself, a little, in the open way of someone who does not make a mystery of herself. She had joined the academy two months ago, she said, because her daughter had started, and because she had sat on the bench and watched, and because one evening she had thought that she would like to learn too, not to be good at it, not to compete, but to understand what her daughter was doing, and to move her own body in a way that her office job did not ask her to. She said that she was terrible at it, and she said it with a laugh, and then she said that being terrible at it was the point, that there was something freeing about being a beginner at thirty-eight, about not knowing, about being allowed to get it wrong. Sarah listened, and she thought about her own reasons for being in the room, and about how different they were from Grace's, and about how the room held them both anyway, without asking either of them to explain themselves, and she liked Grace Liu, in the simple way that you like a person who is honest about what they do not know.
They talked for a while longer, about the bakery, about the school, about the small geography of Asheville that they both knew, about the way the town changed in the autumn and the way the light came over the mountains in the morning, and Noah came over and joined them, and Liam O'Connor came over too, and the four of them stood by the benches while the room emptied around them, and the conversation moved the way conversations do when no one is in a hurry, from one thing to another, without a plan. Grace asked Noah about his exercises, and he showed her the pendulum, standing in the middle of the mat with his arm hanging loose, and she watched, and she said that it looked easy and that she was sure it was not, and Noah laughed, a real laugh this time, and said that it was harder than it looked, which was something he had learned in the last week and was almost proud of knowing. Liam asked Grace about her class, and she told him about the balance exercise, and about the way she had kept falling over, and about the way her partner had helped her up without making a fuss, and Liam nodded, and said that falling over was part of it, and that the getting up was the part that mattered, and Sarah, listening to her son's friend say that, thought that Liam O'Connor, at sixteen, understood something that some adults never learn. Karen Doyle came over with the notebook, and she asked Grace if she would be back on Saturday, and Grace said she would, and Karen made a note, and Tom Ellery came over, and he asked Noah how the shoulder felt after sitting for an hour, and Noah said it felt fine, and Tom nodded, and said that was good, and that he should keep doing the exercises, and that the mat would wait.