"Police Arrest a Black Woman at Her Own Home—Then Learn She’s a Federal Prosecutor

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I didn't know whether he believed he'd been treated unfairly.

And I didn't need to know.

Still, I found myself thinking about the little boy.

He had looked at his father with complete trust.

The same kind of trust I had once placed in adults who wore uniforms.

That thought troubled me.

I mentioned it to Camille over lunch the following week.

She listened while I described the encounter.

Then she asked, “Are you feeling guilty?”

I considered the question.

“No.”

“Are you sure?”

“I don't feel responsible for his choices.”

“Good.”

I stirred my coffee.

“But I don't enjoy knowing his family has been affected.”

Camille nodded.

“That sounds like empathy.”

I looked at her.

“Is that supposed to make me feel better?”

“Not necessarily.”

She smiled.

“It just means you're capable of recognizing another person's humanity without excusing their conduct.”

I leaned back.

“I thought I'd feel something different if I saw him again.”

“Like what?”

“Anger.”

“Did you?”

“A little.”

“Anything else?”

“Sadness.”

Camille nodded.

“That makes sense.”

I looked out the restaurant window.

“Sometimes I wish there were a clean ending.”

She smiled faintly.

“You're a prosecutor. You know better.”

I laughed.

She was right.

A verdict was not the same as an ending.

A settlement was not the same as healing.

And accountability did not require every person involved to disappear from one another's lives.

Sometimes the past simply appeared outside a grocery store.

And you had to decide how to carry it home.

That summer, Rebecca Whitfield asked me to supervise a new group of assistant United States attorneys.

They were talented, ambitious, and full of the certainty that often comes before experience teaches a person how complicated the world can be.

One of them was a young attorney named Daniel Price.

He had graduated near the top of his law school class and spent two years clerking for a federal judge.

He was exceptionally bright.

He also had a habit of assuming that the strongest argument was always the one delivered with the greatest confidence.

During a training session, he presented a hypothetical case involving a disputed police report.

He argued that the officer's account should be given substantial weight because the officer had no obvious reason to lie.

I asked him a question.

“What evidence supports the officer's version?”

Daniel glanced at his notes.

“The report itself.”

“What else?”

“The officer's experience.”

I nodded.

“Anything independent?”

He hesitated.

“Not in the hypothetical.”

I leaned against the conference table.

“Then why are you treating the report as proof rather than as one account that needs examination?”

He looked uncomfortable.

“Because officers are trained observers.”

“Some are. Many are excellent at their jobs. But training doesn't make anyone incapable of error.”

He nodded.

I continued.

“And experience doesn't eliminate the possibility of dishonesty.”

The room became quiet.

Daniel looked at his notes.

“So what should we do?”

“Investigate.”

He smiled slightly.

“Of course.”

“No,” I said. “I mean actually investigate. Don't simply collect material that supports the first version of events. Look for information that could prove it wrong.”

I turned toward the rest of the group.

“If the government's case depends on a witness being accurate, we need to examine accuracy. If it depends on a witness being honest, we need to examine credibility. And if evidence contradicts our theory, we don't hide from it.”

Several attorneys began taking notes.

I looked back at Daniel.

“The job isn't to win every argument.”

He nodded.

“The job is to seek justice.”

“Exactly.”

Afterward, Daniel approached me.

“Can I ask you something?”

“Sure.”

“Was that based on your experience in Fairview?”

I looked at him.

“In part.”

He hesitated.

“I read about what happened.”

I nodded.

“I figured.”

He looked embarrassed.

“I didn't mean to sound insensitive.”

“You didn't.”

“I just never thought about a report that way.”

I studied him.

“Then today was useful.”

He smiled.

“Yes, ma'am.”

As he walked away, I realized that my experience had begun changing how I taught.

Not because I distrusted every officer.

I didn't.

I had worked with outstanding investigators throughout my career.

But I had become more conscious of how easily professional confidence could turn into unquestioned assumption.

That lesson belonged in every courtroom.

In September, I received an invitation to speak at a law school.

The event was part of a series on professional responsibility and public trust.

The organizer asked whether I would discuss the relationship between prosecutors and law enforcement.

I agreed.

I did not plan to speak extensively about my arrest.

By then, I was tired of seeing my name attached to the same headline.

But during the question-and-answer session, a student raised her hand.

She was a young Black woman sitting near the front.

“Ms. Mercer,” she said, “can I ask you something personal?”

I nodded.

“You can ask. I may not answer.”

A few people laughed.

She smiled nervously.

“When the officer arrested you, did you tell him what you did for a living?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

I considered the question.

“Because my profession wasn't relevant to whether I owned my home.”

She nodded.

“But do you think he would have treated you differently if he'd known?”

“Possibly.”

“Then why didn't you tell him?”

I looked around the auditorium.

The students were listening closely.

News in the same category

"Police Arrest a Black Woman at Her Own Home—Then Learn She’s a Federal Prosecutor

30 Part