Grant looked toward the dispatch summary.
“Someone entered that classification.”
Mercer studied the screen.
The initial call notes were visible.
So was a later supplemental entry.
The supplemental entry had been added four minutes after Margaret's call ended.
It stated:
Possible suspect removing landscaping materials. Caller concerned about ongoing neighborhood thefts.
Mercer frowned.
“Who added that?”
Grant checked the record.
Then looked up.
“Dispatch supervisor's office.”
Mercer stared.
“Why?”
Grant hesitated.
“I don't know.”
Mercer looked toward Margaret's house.
Then toward Rourke.
“Find out.”
Margaret Whitfield had not intended to become the center of a police investigation.
She had intended to make a point.
For nearly three years, she had been frustrated by Carla Morris's refusal to follow what Margaret considered the proper landscaping style for Willow Creek Lane.
The neighborhood association had published a voluntary design guide recommending clipped hedges, symmetrical flower beds, and restrained color palettes.
Margaret treated the guide as though it were law.
Carla did not.
Her roses were bright.
Her hydrangeas were full.
She planted lavender along the walkway and allowed climbing jasmine to grow around the porch railing.
The garden was beautiful.
But it was not uniform.
Margaret disliked that.
She disliked it even more because Carla never seemed interested in arguing.
When Margaret complained about the roses, Carla smiled politely.
When Margaret suggested replacing the lavender with boxwood, Carla thanked her for the recommendation.
When Margaret mentioned that the association preferred neutral landscaping, Carla explained that the guidelines were voluntary.
Margaret interpreted Carla's calm responses as arrogance.
And because she knew Carla was a judge, she became convinced that Carla believed ordinary neighborhood rules did not apply to her.
The truth was simpler.
Carla knew the difference between a recommendation and a binding restriction.
Margaret did not like being reminded of it.
Three months before the police incident, Margaret had attended a neighborhood association meeting.
Carla was absent because she was presiding over a late emergency hearing.
Margaret used the opportunity to raise the landscaping issue.
“These oversized rosebushes are changing the character of Willow Creek Lane,” she told the group.
A younger homeowner named Priya Shah looked confused.
“Changing it how?”
“They're visually inconsistent.”
Priya glanced at the photographs Margaret had brought.
“They're flowers.”
Margaret stiffened.
“It's about standards.”
Another homeowner, James Holloway, leaned back.
“My wife loves those roses.”
Margaret ignored him.
“I think we need stronger enforcement.”
The association president, Leonard Price, shook his head.
“We don't have an enforceable rule against rosebushes.”
“Then we should create one.”
Leonard sighed.
“Margaret, we can't create a rule solely because you dislike one person's garden.”
She looked offended.
“That's not what I'm doing.”
But several people in the room knew it was exactly what she was doing.
The motion went nowhere.
Margaret left furious.
Two weeks later, she began taking photographs of Carla's garden.
At first, she told herself she was documenting landscaping violations.
Then she started photographing Carla herself.
Watering.
Pruning.
Carrying mulch.
Working in the flower beds.
She had no legitimate reason to do so.
But resentment has a way of turning ordinary behavior into evidence of imagined wrongdoing.
By the morning of the police call, Margaret had convinced herself that Carla's garden represented a challenge to the entire neighborhood.
And when she saw a woman in old clothes cutting roses, she decided the police could settle a dispute the association had refused to pursue.
At 10:03 a.m., Captain Mercer knocked on Carla's door.
Angela opened it.
“Captain.”
“Ms. Brooks.”
He looked toward Carla.
“Judge Morris, may I speak with you?”
Carla stood.
“Yes.”
Mercer stepped inside.
He noticed the compress on her wrist.
“Have you received medical attention?”
“Not yet.”
“I recommend having the injury examined.”
“I intend to.”
He nodded.
Then looked toward Angela.
“Would you prefer to speak privately?”
Carla shook her head.
“Angela can stay.”
Mercer accepted that.
He took a seat.
“Judge Morris, we've reviewed the original dispatch recording.”
Carla waited.
“The caller did not clearly report witnessing a theft.”
Angela stopped writing.
Carla remained still.
Mercer continued.
“She described someone cutting plants and raised concerns about the appearance of your garden.”
Carla stared.
“The appearance?”
“Yes.”
Carla looked toward the window.
Then back at him.
“Captain, are you telling me the police were dispatched because my neighbor dislikes my roses?”
Mercer chose his words carefully.
“I'm telling you that the original call does not support the description of an observed plant theft.”
Carla nodded slowly.
“That is a significant distinction.”
“Yes.”
“Who changed the description?”
“We're examining that.”
Carla studied him.
“Was the information altered before Officer Rourke arrived?”
“It appears the supplemental entry was made before the officers reached the scene.”
She took a breath.
“Then I want that preserved, too.”
“It will be.”
Angela leaned forward.
“Captain, is Officer Rourke still on duty?”
Mercer hesitated.
“He has been removed from the scene.”
“That wasn't my question.”
Carla glanced toward Angela.
Mercer answered.
“He is being reassigned pending preliminary review.”
Carla nodded.
“Captain, I appreciate you taking this seriously.”
He looked at her.
“But?”
She gave a faint smile.
“You're learning how I speak.”
Mercer almost smiled.
Carla continued.
“I want to be clear that I am not asking you to reach a conclusion before reviewing the evidence.”