Elijah had. His keyboard at home was secondhand, bought with money saved across a whole summer, its case scuffed and its stand slightly uneven on the apartment's sloping floor. The first time a key stuck, he had panicked, certain he had ruined the only instrument he owned. His mother had found him sitting on the floor beside it, close to tears, and instead of calling a repairman they could not afford, she had handed him a pencil and said, with the calm of someone stating a fact, that most things that stick can be coaxed loose if you are gentle and patient. He had learned, over the next three fixes, exactly how: the key lifted from the underside, never forced from above; the pencil angled into the gap like a lever rather than a pry bar; the obstruction — an eraser crumb once, a corner of paper once, a broken fingernail once, a twist of thread once — teased out and held up to the light in triumph. Four times he had fixed it. Four times the keyboard had sung clean again afterward, and he had sat down and played something slow and private, as if to thank it.
Now, in Room 114, he sat very still and listened to the buzz, and he felt the familiar pull between two lessons Hargrove had taught him. The first was the lesson of the back row: do not draw attention, do not touch what is not yours, do not give the school a reason to remember your name for the wrong thing. The second was older and quieter, and it came from his mother's kitchen and the music room at the youth center, and it said that a thing left buzzing only gets worse, and that a person who knows how to fix something and walks away from it has made a choice too.
He looked at the Roland again. From his seat, he could see the F key sitting just slightly lower than its neighbors, the way a tired eyelid sits lower than the other. He could see the dust along the back edge of the case, undisturbed for weeks, and the pitch bend wheel with its small nick in the plastic. The keyboard was school property, and Mr. Pearson had never once invited a student to touch it. But the buzz went on, thin and constant, and Elijah thought about the poetry unit the previous month, when Pearson had played something soft in the background and the buzz had been there underneath the poem like a wrong note nobody commented on, and about how a room full of people could hear a thing and still not hear it, because hearing it would mean doing something about it.
Mr. Pearson turned a page. The rain thickened against the window. The girl with the violin case, two rows over, glanced toward the back wall and frowned slightly, as if she too had caught the edge of the sound without knowing what it was. Elijah's hands were very still on his desk. His pencil lay beside his notebook, ordinary and yellow, its eraser worn flat. He thought about the four fixes at home, about the way each one had felt in his fingers, the small resistance and then the release, and about how thirty seconds of careful work could return a whole instrument to itself.
Then Mr. Pearson closed his paperback, stood, and said he would be just a moment, and stepped into the hallway to speak with another teacher, his voice already fading into the corridor's murmur as the door swung shut behind him. The room exhaled. Someone turned a page loudly. Someone else whispered something that made two heads bend together. And Elijah Carter, thirteen years old, five rows from the front and one row from the wall, put his pencil in his pocket, slid out of his seat, and stood.
Elijah crossed the room the way he had crossed every room at Hargrove for eight months: quietly, without hurry, along the line of the wall where the shadows fell thickest. The floorboards near the back did not creak — he knew that because he had tested them, once, on a day when he had stayed late to return a library book and the room had been empty and his own footsteps had seemed very loud. He passed the shelf of encyclopedias, their spines faded to the color of old tea, and the radiator, which gave off a dry, iron smell, and then he was standing beside the Roland, close enough to see the fine grain of dust on its keys and the small, telltale dip of the F above middle C.