“Politicians can be attacked too.”
Higgins stared at him.
“What do you mean?”
Rizzo opened his briefcase.
“We change the story.”
“How?”
“We say he provoked you.”
Higgins hesitated.
“He did refuse to identify himself.”
“Exactly.”
“But he said he was mayor.”
“We'll say you had reason to doubt him.”
Rizzo leaned closer.
“Then we find something embarrassing about Sterling.”
Higgins slowly nodded.
For the first time since his arrest, hope returned.
“So I'm not finished?”
Rizzo smiled.
“Not even close.”
But there was one thing Rizzo didn't understand.
Beatatrice Sterling had spent his entire political career documenting everything.
Every meeting.
Every accusation.
Every decision.
He didn't fight rumors with rumors.
He fought them with evidence.
And he had evidence.
The City Divides
For two weeks, Oak Creek became a battlefield of public opinion.
Supporters of Higgins claimed the mayor had abused his power.
Others demanded Higgins's prosecution.
Rizzo appeared on television.
He spoke confidently.
“Officer Higgins believed his life was in danger.”
Blogs sympathetic to the police union published stories questioning Beatatrice.
Some claimed he had behaved aggressively.
Others suggested he had deliberately staged the confrontation.
The truth became buried beneath speculation.
Then Beatatrice announced a public town hall.
Two thousand citizens filled the Oak Creek Community Center.
Higgins sat in the front row beside Rizzo.
He wore a tailored suit.
Rizzo had paid for it.
“You look like a victim,” Rizzo whispered.
Higgins smiled.
“I feel like one.”
The lights dimmed.
Beatatrice walked onto the stage.
His ribs were still healing.
He moved carefully.
But his voice remained steady.
“Thank you for coming.”
The crowd quieted.
“Our city is hurting.”
Rizzo stood.
“The city is hurting because you've destroyed the reputation of a police officer!”
Several people applauded.
Beatatrice waited.
Rizzo continued.
“Officer Higgins feared for his life.”
Beatatrice looked at Higgins.
“Is that your statement?”
Higgins stood.
“Yes.”
“Were you afraid?”
“Yes.”
“Did I threaten you?”
“You refused to identify yourself.”
“Did I strike you?”
“No.”
“Did I reach for a weapon?”
Higgins hesitated.
“You moved toward your pocket.”
“My wallet was in my pocket.”
“You could have had a gun.”
Beatatrice nodded.
“I see.”
He turned toward the audience.
“So Officer Higgins says he feared for his life.”
Higgins folded his arms.
“Yes.”
Beatatrice looked toward the technician.
“Play the recording.”
Rizzo jumped up.
“What recording?”
Beatatrice smiled faintly.
“The one Officer Higgins forgot existed.”
The Truth
The screen remained black.
Only audio played.
A police cruiser door slammed.
Then came Higgins's voice.
“Got another one.”
The audience became silent.
His tone was casual.
Almost amused.
“Stupid thug.”
Higgins's face turned white.
Rizzo whispered:
“What's this?”
The recording continued.
“Think you can walk around my town?”
A gasp moved through the auditorium.
Then:
“Mayor? Yeah, right.”
Higgins looked toward the exit.
Beatatrice remained motionless.
The audio continued.
“I'll write it up as resisting. My word against his.”
Someone in the crowd shouted:
“That's him!”
The recording continued.
Then Higgins's voice:
“Going to toss him in the tank for forty-eight hours. Teach him a lesson.”
The auditorium erupted.
Higgins stood.
“That isn't—”
“It's fake!”
Beatatrice raised his hand.
The recording continued.
“You can do whatever you want to these people. They just take it.”
Silence.
Then the audio ended.
For several seconds, nobody moved.