Donnelly followed them to the patch of grass and stopped a few feet away, his thumbs hooked back into his belt, his posture as rigid as it had been when he first approached. "Now," he said, "let's try this again. Identification. Real identification. Driver's licenses. Both of you."
"We have already provided identification," Sarah said. "I have provided mine. My husband will provide his. But I want the record to be clear that my judicial identification card was presented first, and that you declined to verify it."
"I don't care about your record," Donnelly said. "I care about what I can see with my own eyes. And what I see is a card that doesn't look right, in a park where you don't belong, at a time when you shouldn't be here."
Marcus reached for his own wallet, slowly, narrating his movements the way he had been taught to do in moments like this, though no one had ever taught him in words, only in the accumulated caution of a lifetime. "I am reaching for my wallet, Officer," he said. "It is in my back pocket. I am taking it out now." He drew it free and opened it and took out his driver's license, and he held it out, and Donnelly took it this time, snatched it, really, his fingers closing around the small plastic card, and he looked at it for a long moment, turning it over in his hand, studying the photograph, studying the name.
"Marcus Harrington," he read aloud, and the sound of his own name in the officer's mouth made Marcus flinch inwardly, though he did not show it. "Senior architect, is that right? That's what you told me earlier?"
"I am a senior architect," Marcus said. "At a firm in the city. My wife is a District Court Judge. We live in this area. We come to this park often."
"Often," Donnelly repeated, as if the word itself were suspicious. "And nobody's ever stopped you before?"
"No," Marcus said. "No one has ever stopped us before."
Donnelly handed the license back, but he did not hand it back the way a person hands something back. He held it out at arm's length, letting it dangle between two fingers, making Marcus step forward to take it, making the taking itself a small act of submission. Marcus took it without a word and put it back in his wallet, and he put his wallet back in his pocket, and he stood with his hands at his sides again, open and empty.
"And you," Donnelly said, turning back to Sarah. "Your license. Let's see it."
Sarah reached into her wallet with the same steady hand and drew out her driver's license, and she held it out beside the judicial card, so that both were visible at once, so that no one watching could mistake what she was offering. "My driver's license," she said. "And my judicial identification card. Both are in my name. Both carry my photograph. Both are genuine."
Donnelly took the license and glanced at it, and then his eyes moved to the judicial card again, and his mouth tightened. "This," he said, tapping the judicial card with one fingertip, hard enough to make it flex in her hand, "this is the problem. You keep showing me this like it means something. It doesn't mean anything to me. Anybody can print a card. Anybody can put a seal on a piece of plastic."
"It was issued by the court," Sarah said. "It is not printed at home. It is not a prop. It is the identification I am issued as a judge, and it is the identification I carry when I am not in my courtroom, so that I can be identified as a judge when I need to be."
"You're not in your courtroom now," Donnelly said. "You're in my park. And in my park, a judge is just a person on a blanket who needs to show me a real ID."
The word "my" landed heavily, and Sarah heard it the way she heard everything Donnelly said, as a claim being staked, a boundary being drawn around a public place and made private by the force of one man's certainty. She did not argue with it. She had learned, in her years on the bench, that arguing with a claim only gave it more weight, and that the better course was to state the facts again, plainly, and let them stand beside the claim until the difference between them became impossible to ignore.