Rest of story – HOA PAVED A BIKE PATH THROUGH MY CATTLE PASTURE — THEN ONE CONSERVATION LAW DESTROYED THEIR BOARD

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Did you respond to the letter?"

"I don't recall responding."

"The August 2006 letter?" She slid it across. "The January 2007 letter?"

"I don't recall."

"You don't recall receiving three certified letters from the owner of the land your community occupies, informing you that your lease had expired?"

"I recall receiving correspondence. I don't recall the specifics."

Rebecca let the silence sit. Court reporters love silence — it transcribes as "(pause)," which reads beautifully later.

"Mr. Whitmore, let's talk about the 2007 email." She produced it. "Did you write this?"

Pryce: "Objection. Attorney-client privilege."

"The email was sent to the full board and produced in discovery after privilege was waived," Rebecca said. "Mr. Whitmore, did you write it?"

Another whispered conference. "I don't recall writing it, but it appears to be from my account."

"'Counsel recommends we take no action that acknowledges Mr. Caldwell's ownership, as acknowledgment could undermine a future claim of adverse possession.' Do you recall this strategy?"

"I recall that we sought legal advice on protecting the community."

"By concealing the expiration of the lease from the residents?"

"We acted on counsel's advice."

"Did counsel advise you to remove references to the Caldwell lease from the new resident orientation materials?"

"I don't recall."

Rebecca produced the Abernathy memo — November 2005, Arthur's signature, directing the welcome committee to scrub the lease references. "Is this your signature, Mr. Whitmore?"

Long pause. "Yes."

"This memo is dated November 2005 — a month before the lease expired. You were already removing evidence of the lease before it even ended. Why?"

Pryce: "Objection. Argumentative."

"You can answer."

"I — the community's messaging needed to be consistent."

"Consistent with what?"

"With — with the community's position."

"Which was?"

"That the amenities belong to the community."

"Mr. Whitmore, did the amenities belong to the community in November 2005?"

"They — the community had invested —"

"It's a yes or no question. The lease was still in effect in November 2005. The land belonged to Ellis Caldwell. The agreement said so. Did the amenities 'belong to the community'?"

"I believe the community had equitable interests."

"Equitable interests." Rebecca made a note. "We'll come back to that. Let's discuss Whitmore Holdings LLC."

Arthur went rigid. Pryce shifted in his chair.

"You formed this LLC in January of this year. Correct?"

"Yes."

"And the HOA transferred its interest in the recreational parcel improvements to Whitmore Holdings for ten dollars. Correct?"

"It was a board-approved restructuring."

"Approved at a meeting with two members present, on twenty minutes' notice. Is that your recollection?"

"The bylaws permit emergency meetings."

"Was there an emergency?"

News in the same category

Rest of story – HOA PAVED A BIKE PATH THROUGH MY CATTLE PASTURE — THEN ONE CONSERVATION LAW DESTROYED THEIR BOARD

20 Part