"Do you think the original consulting agreement was improper?"
Helen closed the folder.
"That's what the review is intended to determine."
Thomas nodded.
He did not ask again.
Friday's meeting began at 9:30 a.m.
Richard entered the conference room with Martin and an attorney from his outside legal team.
Amelia Grant was already seated.
Helen Park sat beside Daniel Price.
The external adviser, a woman named Laura Chen, had a laptop open in front of her.
She introduced herself and explained the purpose of the meeting.
"This is a fact-finding session. We are not making conclusions today. We will review the documents, ask questions, and identify any additional information required."
Richard nodded.
"I understand."
Laura began with the original consulting agreement.
"Mr. Whitmore, can you confirm that your firm's role was limited to market research, vendor comparison, preliminary planning, and executive reporting?"
"Yes."
"Did the agreement authorize Whitmore Consulting Group to select subcontractors?"
"No."
"Did it authorize your firm to receive compensation from a proposed vendor?"
"Not without written disclosure and approval."
"Was Meridian Strategic Partners introduced by your firm?"
"Yes."
"Did you disclose that your sister's trust held a financial interest in Meridian?"
Richard paused.
"No."
Laura looked at him.
"Why not?"
Richard adjusted his chair.
"At the time, I didn't believe the relationship was material to the introduction."
"Why?"
"Because Meridian was being considered for its capabilities."
"Did you know about the family interest when you introduced the company?"
"Yes."
"Then why was it not disclosed?"
Richard looked toward his attorney.
His attorney did not interrupt.
"I believed the interest was sufficiently indirect that it did not affect the recommendation."
Laura made a note.
"Did you seek legal advice before making that decision?"
"No."
"Did you seek approval from Sterling's procurement department?"
"No."
"Did you seek approval from Sterling's compliance department?"
"No."
Richard looked down.
Laura turned to another document.
"This email, dated six weeks ago, states that Meridian's involvement should be treated as a practical requirement rather than a separate vendor selection. Can you explain that?"
Richard nodded.
"I believed Meridian could help coordinate implementation."
"Did you have a written scope of work?"
"Not at that point."
"Did Meridian have a formal role in the project?"
"Not yet."
"Then what made its participation a practical requirement?"
Richard hesitated.
"Experience. Relationships. Familiarity with the project."
"Can you identify the specific services?"
"Not in detail."
Laura looked at the document.
"Would you agree that the statement was premature?"
Richard's attorney spoke.
"My client can answer."
Richard nodded.
"Yes. In retrospect, the wording was premature."
Laura continued.
"Let's discuss the proposed coordination fee."
She displayed the financial proposal.
"Was this prepared by Meridian?"
"Yes."
"Was it requested by Whitmore Consulting Group?"
Richard looked at the page.
"We discussed the possibility of a continuing coordination role."
"Did you ask Sterling to consider a fee tied to the total contract value?"
"Yes."
"Why was a percentage-based fee appropriate?"
"Because the overall project was substantial, and the coordination work would be extensive."
"Did you prepare a detailed breakdown of the work?"
"No."
"Did you calculate the fee based on estimated hours, personnel, or deliverables?"
"No."
"Then how was the percentage determined?"
Richard was silent.
Finally, he said, "It was a commercial proposal."
Laura nodded.
"Understood. But was there a calculation supporting it?"
"No."
The room became quiet.
Laura turned to Amelia.
"That concludes the initial questions."
Amelia looked toward Richard.
"Do you understand why this has become a serious issue?"
Richard nodded.
"I do."
"Sterling cannot approve a vendor arrangement based on undisclosed relationships and undefined responsibilities."
"I understand."
"Your firm was trusted to advise us. That trust requires transparency."
Richard looked at the table.
"I recognize that."
Amelia continued.
"The review will proceed. Until it is complete, Whitmore Consulting Group will have no role in the Northstar implementation process."
Richard looked up.
"You're suspending the entire engagement?"
"Yes."
"For how long?"
"Until the review is complete."
Richard's attorney leaned forward.
"We would appreciate a written statement of the suspension terms."
Helen nodded.
"You will receive one."
The meeting ended at 11:15 a.m.
Richard walked out without speaking.
Martin followed him.
In the elevator, Richard finally turned.
"Did you know it would go that way?"
Martin shook his head.
"No."
"Do you think they have already decided?"
"I think they have decided they need the facts."
Richard stared at the floor numbers.
"That may be worse."
That afternoon, Caroline Whitmore called her brother.
She sounded angry.
"Why is Sterling asking for my trust documents?"
Richard closed his office door.
"Because Meridian was introduced into the Northstar project."
"You told me this was a routine consulting opportunity."
"It was."
"Then why are they asking about ownership?"
"Because the relationship wasn't disclosed."
Caroline was silent.
Then she said, "You told me it didn't need to be disclosed."
Richard rubbed his forehead.
"I thought it was indirect."
"You said there was no conflict."
"I said I didn't believe it created a conflict."
"That's not the same thing."
Richard looked at the desk.