Margaret closed her eyes.
"Why?"
"They said it was needed for a restructuring plan."
"Did you provide it?"
"No."
Margaret exhaled slowly.
"Good."
"I wasn't sure whether I had the authority to refuse."
"You did the right thing."
Elaine hesitated.
"There's more."
Margaret waited.
"One of the employees I interviewed contacted me last Friday. He said someone had been asking questions about what he told us."
"Who?"
"Thomas Bell. He works in vendor compliance."
"Did he say who was asking?"
"He described a man with gray hair who carried a black leather folder."
Margaret looked at the photograph in her hand.
The same man.
"Elaine, listen carefully. I need you to do exactly what I'm about to tell you."
She gave the auditor a set of instructions. Preserve the original files. Keep a separate record of every contact related to the review. Do not discuss the matter with anyone outside the approved investigation group.
When the call ended, Margaret remained standing for several seconds.
Then she returned to Richard's office.
He was reading a printed report when she entered.
"I spoke to Elaine Foster," Margaret said.
Richard looked up.
"And?"
"The audit was suspended using a message that appeared to come from my office. I never sent it."
Richard set down the report.
"Who received it?"
"The head of internal audit. She was also asked to prepare a list of everyone interviewed during the review."
"Did she comply?"
"No."
"Good."
Margaret placed a folder on his desk.
"There's a vendor issue too. Three companies have received payments from different divisions. Their addresses appear to be connected, and all three were introduced by the same procurement manager."
Richard opened the folder.
"Who?"
"Victor Harlan."
Richard looked up.
"Victor?"
"Yes."
Victor Harlan was Whitmore's senior vice president of procurement. He had worked for the company for eighteen years and had helped negotiate several of its largest contracts.
Richard had promoted him twice.
"What is the value of the payments?" Richard asked.
"Preliminary total: just under four million dollars over fourteen months."
"Are the services legitimate?"
"Some may be. Others are difficult to verify."
"Has Victor been interviewed?"
"Not yet."
"Why not?"
"Because the audit was suspended before the team could reach him."
Richard leaned back.
"Convenient."
Margaret nodded.
"I thought so too."
He examined the report more carefully.
The vendors were listed as Meridian Strategic Advisory, Northbridge Operations Group, and Vantage Continuity Partners.
Each company claimed to provide specialized consulting services.
Their descriptions were vague.
Meridian offered "executive risk coordination."
Northbridge billed for "operational efficiency reviews."
Vantage provided "strategic continuity support."
The invoices included substantial charges for meetings, reports, and advisory sessions, but the supporting documents were incomplete.
Richard tapped the page.
"Who signed the contracts?"
"Victor's department."
"Who approved the payments?"
"Different finance managers in three separate divisions."
"Who verified the services?"
Margaret shook her head.
"That's one of the problems. In several cases, the verification field contains a generic approval code rather than an employee's name."
Richard studied the documents.
"How long has this been happening?"
"The earliest payment I found was fourteen months ago."
"And the security clearance changes began six weeks ago."
"Yes."
Richard closed the folder.
"We may be looking at two related problems. Someone has been moving money through questionable vendors, and someone has recently begun manipulating security procedures."
Margaret nodded.
"Which raises the question of why now."
"Perhaps someone believes the audit is getting too close."
"Or someone wants us to focus on security while the financial records disappear."
Richard considered that possibility.
It was plausible.
The note, the photograph, the staged confrontation, and the unauthorized access changes could have been designed to distract them from the vendor payments.
But the evidence was not yet sufficient to support a conclusion.
He opened his notebook and added another question.
Who benefits from the audit being suspended?
Margaret watched him write.
"Richard, there's something else."
He looked up.
"What?"
"I reviewed the building's executive calendar for the past two months. Someone has been accessing your schedule outside the normal permissions."
"Who?"
"The access log identifies an administrative account, but the account was disabled several weeks ago."
"Can it be traced?"
"IT says the records are incomplete."
"Of course they are."
Margaret gave him a tired look.
"This is becoming a pattern."
"Yes."
"Someone alters a record. Someone else removes the evidence. And every time we ask who authorized it, the answer is missing."
Richard closed his notebook.
"Then we stop asking the compromised system to explain itself."
Margaret frowned.
"What do you mean?"
"We preserve the information outside the network. We collect original documents. We speak directly to people. We create an independent chain of records that cannot be changed by a single administrator."