"What letter?"
Mara took it from her backpack and handed it to him.
He recognized his handwriting immediately. His fingers trembled as he unfolded the paper. He read it slowly, moving his lips over the words he had written three years earlier.
When he finished, he sat down.
"She never answered."
"She might have been afraid."
"Of what?"
Mara thought of Thomas's explanation.
"Of the people involved with Saint Agnes."
Daniel gave a bitter laugh.
"After all this time, that is still the easiest explanation. Fear. Everyone was afraid. Everyone had something to lose. And somehow, I was the only person who lost everything."
Mara did not know what to say.
Daniel folded the letter and placed it beside him.
"Why are you here, Miss Ellis?"
"Because my grandmother left me a note. She told me to find you."
He looked up.
"She did?"
Mara showed him the note and the photograph of Samuel. Daniel took the photograph with both hands, and for a moment he seemed unable to breathe.
"Where did you find this?"
"In a box in her bedroom."
He stared at the boy's face.
"Samuel."
His voice broke on the name.
Mara had expected sadness, perhaps anger, but seeing Daniel hold the photograph was like watching someone touch a wound that had never healed.
"He was seven when I last saw him," Daniel said. "He had a habit of whistling when he was nervous. He couldn't carry a tune, but he insisted that he was learning a song from the radio."
He smiled faintly.
"Every morning, he would stand beside the kitchen sink and whistle the same four notes. When I told him he was making a terrible noise, he would say that one day he would become the best musician in the world."
Daniel lowered the photograph.
"I used to tell him that I would be there when he performed his first concert."
Mara looked at the photograph.
"Do you think he's alive?"
The question seemed to take Daniel by surprise.
He looked toward the window, where the harbor lights trembled in the dark water.
"For a long time, I believed he was. I searched every town I could reach. I wrote to newspapers. I hired people when I had enough money. I followed rumors that turned out to be lies. Eventually, I began to wonder whether hope had become another way of punishing myself."
"But you never stopped looking."
"No." He rubbed his thumb along the edge of the photograph. "I stopped traveling. I stopped believing that I would find him. But I never stopped wondering."
Mara took out Thomas's notebook and showed him the entry about the possible sighting in 2018.
Daniel read it once.
Then he read it again.
"Where did Thomas get this?"
"He received a call from a woman at a community shelter. A man called Sam Miller had arrived there. He had no identification and a scar beneath his left eye."
Daniel's hand began to shake.
"Did Thomas say which shelter?"
Mara gave him the name.
He stood so quickly that the chair scraped across the floor.
"That shelter closed years ago."
"Do you know where the records went?"
"Perhaps to the county office. Perhaps nowhere. These places change names, move buildings, lose paperwork. People disappear from one system and never enter another."
"But we can try."
Daniel looked at her.
For the first time since she had arrived, his expression was not entirely guarded. Beneath the grief was a fragile, almost frightened possibility.
"Why would you do this for me?"
Mara had asked herself the same question during the bus ride.
"Because my grandmother wanted me to."
"That isn't enough."
"Because I want to know why she kept all of this from me. Because I want to know what happened at Saint Agnes. And because if Samuel is alive, I don't think he should spend another day believing nobody wants to find him."
Daniel looked down at the photograph again.
"You sound like Elizabeth."
Mara felt a sting of resentment.
"Then perhaps you knew a different woman from the one who raised me."
He looked at her sharply.
"What do you mean?"
"My grandmother was kind. She took care of me after my mother died. She made sure I went to school, helped me with my homework, and sat beside my bed whenever I was sick. But she never told me about you. She never told me about Samuel. She left me a letter after she died, as if the truth could wait until there was nobody left to question her."
Daniel did not answer immediately.
At last, he said, "Elizabeth was a complicated woman."
"Everybody is."
"Yes. But some people become very good at hiding the parts of themselves they cannot forgive."
Mara thought about that.
"Did you hate her?"
Daniel looked toward the workbench.
"For a while."
"What changed?"
"Nothing changed. I simply became too tired to carry hatred everywhere I went."
He returned the photograph to her, then moved toward a filing cabinet.
"Wait here."
He opened the top drawer and searched through a collection of folders, receipts, and old letters. After several minutes, he removed a small envelope marked with a date from the previous year.
"I received this from a lawyer in your grandmother's town," he said. "He wrote to ask whether I would be willing to make a statement concerning the Saint Agnes restoration fund. I never answered."
"Why not?"
"Because I thought it was another attempt to drag me back into a life I had spent years escaping."
He handed her the envelope.
Inside was a letter from a solicitor named Andrew Collins. It explained that certain documents relating to the church's restoration fund had recently been discovered in a storage facility. The solicitor represented the estate of Arthur Bell, the former treasurer of Saint Agnes, who had died several months earlier.
The documents, the letter stated, might be relevant to an unresolved dispute concerning funds that had disappeared before the fire.
At the bottom was a handwritten note.
Mr. Mercer, I believe you were wrongly accused. Please contact me at your earliest convenience.
Mara looked up.
"Why didn't you tell Thomas about this?"
"I didn't know what to tell him. I had spent so many years trying to prove I wasn't a thief that I no longer knew whether proving it would make any difference."
"Perhaps it would."
Daniel looked at her.
"To whom?"
She could not answer.
The workshop fell quiet except for the ticking of the electric heater.
After a while, Daniel moved to a small refrigerator and took out two sandwiches wrapped in paper. He placed one in front of Mara.
"You haven't eaten."
"I'm not hungry."
"Neither am I. That doesn't mean our bodies have stopped needing food."
She accepted the sandwich.
They ate in silence, and for the first time since she had arrived, Mara felt her exhaustion. Her eyes burned, and her shoulders ached from carrying the backpack. The long journey, the grief, and the weight of the unanswered questions had left her feeling older than sixteen.
Daniel noticed.
"There is a small guesthouse across the harbor," he said. "Mrs. Alvarez runs it. She knew me when I first came here. If you have nowhere to stay, I can call her."
"I can take the bus home."
"Not tonight. The last service leaves soon, and the road gets dangerous in this weather."
Mara hesitated.
She had not told Mrs. Whitaker where she was going. She had not told anyone at school. Her phone battery was almost dead, and the money in her pocket would barely cover a meal and a return ticket.
"I don't want to be a burden," she said.
Daniel's expression softened.
"You aren't."
He picked up the telephone and dialed a number from memory.
While he spoke to Mrs. Alvarez, Mara wandered toward the shelves at the back of the workshop. A collection of small objects sat beside an old radio: a chipped mug, a brass compass, a wooden toy boat, and a red bicycle bell.
She reached toward the bell.
"Don't touch that."
Daniel's voice was sharp enough to make her withdraw her hand.
He immediately looked ashamed.
"I'm sorry."
Mara glanced at the bell.
"Is it Samuel's?"
Daniel nodded.
"He had a red bicycle. I sold it after he disappeared because I needed money to keep searching. I kept the bell."
He picked it up carefully.
"I told myself that if I ever found him, I would buy him another bicycle. A better one. One with gears and a proper seat. Something a boy his age would have been proud of."
He gave a faint, humorless smile.
"Of course, he would be a man now."
Mara thought of the old photograph.
"Maybe he would still like it."
Daniel looked at her.
"Do you think so?"
"I don't know. But I think people are allowed to want things even when they grow older."
For a moment, Daniel appeared to be considering the answer seriously.
Then he placed the bell back on the shelf.
"Perhaps you're right."
He finished the telephone call and wrote the guesthouse address on a piece of paper. Before Mara left, he gave her a folder containing copies of the letters he had sent while searching for Samuel.
"Take these," he said. "If we're going to look for him, you should know what I tried."
Mara accepted the folder.
"What will you do?"
Daniel glanced toward the photograph.
"What I should have done years ago."
He reached for his coat.
"I'm coming with you."
Mrs. Alvarez's guesthouse stood on a hill overlooking the harbor. It had six rooms, a narrow staircase, and a dining room where the smell of cinnamon and baked apples seemed to linger in the curtains.
The owner was a small woman with silver hair and bright, watchful eyes. When Daniel introduced Mara, she studied the girl's face for a moment before turning toward him.
"She's Elizabeth's granddaughter, isn't she?"
Daniel nodded.
Mrs. Alvarez said nothing more, but she gave Mara a room at a reduced rate and brought up a plate of warm food.
That night, Mara sat at the little desk beneath the window and examined the folder Daniel had given her.
The letters were heartbreaking.
Some were addressed to police departments. Others had been sent to hospitals, schools, and social services offices. Many had been returned unopened. Several contained photographs of Samuel at different ages, each accompanied by a description of his birthmark, his eye color, and the small scar beneath his left eye.
Daniel had written the same sentence in almost every letter.
My son may believe I abandoned him. Please tell him that I have never stopped looking.
Mara read until her eyes blurred.
Then she discovered a letter addressed to Elizabeth Ellis.
It had been written in 2007, only months after Samuel disappeared.
Elizabeth,
I know you believe I should have stayed. Perhaps you are right. Perhaps I should have fought harder, ignored the threats, and refused to let anyone frighten me away from my son.
But I was afraid, and I made a decision I cannot undo.
If you know anything about where Samuel might be, please tell me. I have no pride left to protect. I have no reputation worth saving. I only want my boy home.
I am asking you as a friend, not as someone who owes me anything.
Please.
There was no response attached.
Mara placed the letter on the desk and covered her face with her hands.
She did not know what her grandmother had done, but she knew that silence had cost Daniel something he could never recover.
And she was beginning to suspect that the truth was worse than anything the newspapers had printed.
Before going to bed, she called Mrs. Whitaker.
The social worker answered on the fourth ring.
"Mara? Where are you?"
"At the coast."
There was a long silence.
"Are you safe?"
"Yes."
"Do you understand how worried I've been?"
"I'm sorry. I should have called."
"Yes, you should have."
Mara took a breath.
"I found someone who knew my grandmother."
"Who?"
"Daniel Mercer."
Another silence followed.
This one was different.
"How do you know that name?" Mrs. Whitaker asked.
Mara sat upright.
"You've heard of him?"
"I've seen the name in some of the estate documents."
"What documents?"
"The ones your grandmother asked me to keep separate from the ordinary household paperwork."
Mara felt her heart begin to race.
"What did she say about him?"
Mrs. Whitaker hesitated.
"She told me that if you ever asked about Saint Agnes, I should give you a sealed envelope."
Mara stared at the telephone.
"Where is it?"
"In my office."
"Can you open it?"
"No. Your grandmother specifically instructed me not to open it unless you requested it yourself."
"Then I am requesting it."
"All right," Mrs. Whitaker said quietly. "I'll arrange to meet you tomorrow."
Mara ended the call and sat motionless in the darkness.
She had thought the journey would reveal the truth.
Instead, every answer had led to another locked door.
And somewhere back home, in an office she had barely noticed, her grandmother had left one more secret waiting for her.
Chapter Four
Mara barely slept.
Every time she closed her eyes, she saw the photograph of Samuel beside his red bicycle. She imagined him as a child, frightened and alone, waiting for a father who had promised to return. Then she imagined him as a grown man, moving from place to place with a name that might not have been his own.
The thought that he could still be alive made sleep impossible.
At six in the morning, she went downstairs and found Daniel sitting in the guesthouse dining room. He had arrived before breakfast, carrying a folder and two cups of coffee.
"You look terrible," he said.
"So do you."
He smiled faintly.
"Fair enough."
Mara sat across from him.
"I spoke to Mrs. Whitaker last night. She has another letter from my grandmother."
Daniel's smile disappeared.
"What kind of letter?"
"She didn't say. Apparently, Grandma instructed her to give it to me if I asked about Saint Agnes."
Daniel stared into his coffee.
"Elizabeth always did know how to make things difficult."
"Do you think she knew what happened to Samuel?"
"I don't know."
"But you suspect she did."
He was silent for a long time.
Then he said, "There was a woman named Margaret Bell. She was Arthur Bell's wife. She volunteered at Saint Agnes and helped organize the church's charity programs. She was the last person outside the family who claimed to have seen Samuel before he disappeared."
"Did the police question her?"
"Several times. She said she had no idea what happened. She claimed Samuel had been taken by strangers, but she couldn't explain why she had been the last person to see him."
"Was she involved?"
"I never proved it."
"What happened to her?"
"She moved away after Arthur died. I heard she was living somewhere near the capital, but that was years ago."
Mara wrote the name in her notebook.
"Margaret Bell."
Daniel nodded.
"Your grandmother knew her well. They worked together on the restoration committee."
The name sent a cold feeling through Mara's chest.
If Elizabeth had known Margaret, and Margaret had been the last person to see Samuel, then her grandmother might have known far more than she had ever admitted.
"Why didn't you tell the police about your suspicions?" Mara asked.
"I did. They investigated her, but there was no evidence. She said she had taken Samuel to the church that morning because he wanted to see the stained-glass windows. She claimed she left him with a group of volunteers while she went to collect supplies. When she returned, he was gone."
"That sounds suspicious."
"It was. But suspicion isn't proof."
"Did anyone else see him?"
"A caretaker said he saw Samuel near the side entrance. Another volunteer remembered hearing a child crying. But their statements contradicted each other, and the church records were incomplete."
Mara looked at the folder on the table.
"Maybe the missing records explain why."
"Perhaps."
They spent breakfast examining the old documents. Daniel had organized his letters by year, but several dates were missing, and some pages had been torn from the notebooks. One report contained a handwritten note that had never been included in the newspaper articles.
Possible transfer of funds authorized by A. Bell. Further review required.
Mara pointed to it.
"What's this?"
Daniel leaned closer.
"I've never seen that note before."
"It looks like someone was investigating the money before the fire."
"Yes."
"Who wrote it?"
"The handwriting resembles that of the church secretary, Helen Foster."