If you refuse, I will have no choice but to involve the authorities.
Thomas.
The letter was dated three months before the ownership transfer that had reduced Thomas's share of the property.
Evan felt his jaw tighten.
Sarah read over his shoulder.
"Your father accused mine of taking money."
"Yes."
"And my father kept the letter."
Evan looked at the file box.
"Why would he keep it if he knew he had done something wrong?"
"Maybe he believed he could use it to protect himself."
"Or maybe he thought he could still make things right."
Sarah looked at him.
"You think he regretted it?"
"I think he regretted something. I don't know whether he regretted what he did or only what it cost him."
They continued sorting through the documents.
Several pages appeared to be copies of contracts. Others were handwritten notes about payments, dates, and property values.
Then Sarah found an envelope containing two letters from Evan.
She knew the handwriting.
She held them up with trembling fingers.
"These are yours."
Evan took the first one.
It was one of the letters he had sent Sarah nine years earlier.
He recognized the words on the front.
But this copy had been opened.
Someone had read it.
Inside, a faint pencil mark appeared beside one paragraph.
The paragraph said:
I don't know what Robert has told you, but I need you to know that I have never stopped wanting to come home.
Evan stared at the mark.
Sarah took the letter from him.
"He read it."
"Yes."
She turned it over.
A note was written in her father's handwriting on the back.
Must prevent contact. If she speaks to him, everything will come apart.
Sarah went pale.
Evan felt as though the floor had shifted beneath him.
The note was dated the same week Robert had told Evan that Sarah wanted no further contact.
They had found the lie in the handwriting of the man who created it.
Sarah lowered herself onto a folding chair.
For several moments, she could not speak.
Then she whispered, "He knew."
Evan knelt beside her.
"He knew what he was doing."
She looked at the letter.
"He knew we loved each other. He knew I was waiting for him. He knew I was pregnant."
Her voice broke.
"And he still kept us apart."
Evan did not try to defend Robert.
He did not offer an explanation that might soften the truth.
He simply sat beside her.
Sarah began to cry.
Not the restrained tears she had shed at the diner, nor the silent grief she had carried through the years.
These were the tears of someone discovering that a wound she had spent years learning to live with had been deliberately inflicted.
Evan reached for her hand, then stopped before touching it.
"May I?"
She looked at him.
For a moment, she seemed uncertain.
Then she nodded.
He took her hand.
They sat together among the boxes, surrounded by the documents of a past that had shaped both their lives without their knowledge.
Sarah cried until she had no more words.
Evan stayed.
He did not tell her to stop.
He did not tell her that everything would be all right.
He did not tell her that her father must have had a reason.
He stayed because she needed someone to stay.
And because, after all those years, he finally understood that sometimes the most important thing a person could do was refuse to leave when the truth became painful.
The next morning, Evan called Daniel Price.
He described the documents they had found and arranged to bring them to the office.
Daniel examined the letters, comparing the handwriting and dates. He made copies, noted the location of the original papers, and reviewed the property records with increasing concern.
"This is more significant than I expected," he said.
Evan sat opposite him.
"Can we prove what Robert did?"
"We can prove that he received letters intended for Sarah. We can prove that he retained them. The note on the back suggests deliberate interference, though we will need to establish its authenticity."
"And the property?"
Daniel held up one of the transfer documents.
"The signature attributed to Thomas Hale does not look consistent with the signatures I have on file. That is not enough to establish forgery, but it gives us grounds for a formal review."
"How much money are we talking about?"
Daniel turned to a spreadsheet.
"At the time of the transfer, the value of the property was modest. But the surrounding area developed significantly over the following decades. The property became much more valuable."
Evan stared at the figures.
"How much?"
"If the ownership transfer is invalid, the value of the missing share could be substantial. There may also be questions concerning the revenue generated by the property and the terms of the settlement after your father's death."
Evan sat back.
He had come expecting answers about a lost relationship.
He was now looking at the possibility that his father had been cheated out of a valuable asset.
Daniel closed the folder.
"I want to be very clear. We have evidence worth investigating, not a final judgment. We will need the original records, a forensic review of the signatures, and a full accounting of the ownership history."
Evan nodded.
"Do whatever you need to do."
Daniel studied him.
"This could become expensive and unpleasant. There may be other people involved. If the documents were altered, someone may have helped Robert. You should prepare yourself for the possibility that the truth will implicate more than one person."